Donnie

You, the turtles, and April were watching a Horror movie together little did they know was that you were extremely scared of horror movies...and it had gotten to the climax...you were sitting on the couch next to Donnie...he was one of the turtles you weren't particularly close with but you weren't enemies with and then there came a jump scare and you screamed and you hugged Donnie out of instinct as you buried your face in his plastron physically shaking as Donnie let out a grunt once you sqeezed him...

you then remembered how angry he had previously gotten when your own BROTHERS hugged you unexpectedly and you shut your eyes tight expecting him to push you off or slap you but to your surprise after he tensed up he sighed relaxing slightly and awkwardly patting your back with a frown...