Your Girlfriend Cheats On You With Your Ex

The afternoon light slanted through your blinds in lazy golden stripes as you lounged across your couch, fingers drumming idly against your thigh. The hum of the refrigerator and the distant murmur of city traffic outside created the usual soundtrack of your solitude—until the sharp trill of the doorbell shattered it. You blinked, momentarily disoriented, before padding barefoot across the creaking floorboards to answer.

Talia stood on your welcome mat, the soft blue fabric of her blouse rippling slightly in the breeze, the white skirt swaying just above her knees as she shifted her weight. Sunshine caught in her blonde waves like liquid gold, her cheeks flushed pink from the late summer heat. There was an unusual spark in her emerald eyes, a bounce in her step that hadn’t been there the last time you’d seen her. "Hi," she chirped, slipping past you before you could even greet her properly, the fabric of her skirt brushing against your leg as she beelined for the kitchen. The scent of vanilla and something faintly citrusy trailed after her.

You shut the door slowly, studying her. Talia wasn’t usually this… effervescent. She perched on one of your barstools with a little hop, the white skirt wrinkling slightly beneath her as she settled in, her sandals tapping against the metal footrest. Immediately, she snagged the half-eaten bag of chips left on the counter from last night. Crunching loudly, she grinned at you around a mouthful, and you arched an eyebrow.

Okay, what’s going on?

She swallowed, licking salt from her fingertips with a giggle. "You’re staring at me like I grew a second head." Her shoulders lifted in a sheepish shrug, but the giddy energy didn’t dim. "I guess I’m just… in a good mood?"

You leaned against the fridge, arms crossed, waiting.

Talia squirmed under your scrutiny, twisting a strand of hair around her finger—a nervous habit. Then, as if she couldn’t contain it any longer, the words spilled out: "I made a friend. Like, a real friend. Well—a few weeks ago, actually, but I didn’t want to say anything until I was sure it wasn’t just, y’know, a fluke."

A warmth flickered in your chest. Talia had always been shy, slow to trust, her social circle limited mostly to classmates and, well, you. Seeing her this animated—this happy—over something as simple as a new connection was… nice. Really nice.

She took another chip, the crisp sound sharp in the quiet kitchen. "We met at the library. I was trying to find the newest book in that fantasy series I’ve been obsessed with—the one with the dragonriders?—and she was right there, holding the last copy." Talia’s eyes sparkled at the memory, her fingers tugging absently at the hem of her blouse. "I was so annoyed, but then she turned around, saw me staring, and just… laughed."

Her fingers mimed the scene, scattering crumbs. "She said, ‘You look like I just kicked your puppy,’ and then—then she asked if I’d read the previous ones. Next thing I knew, we were in the corner by the history section ranting about how the author totally fumbled the third-act twist in book three." Talia’s grin widened. "She knew all the obscure lore. Like, details even I’d forgotten. And she—"

A pause. A breath. Talia’s voice softened, almost wistful. "She actually listened when I talked about my theories. Didn’t just nod and zone out like most people do."

Your lips quirked. You knew exactly how that felt—those rare moments when someone genuinely engaged with Talia’s quiet, passionate ramblings. It was one of the things you loved most about her.

You tilted your head, curious. What’s her name?

Talia blinked, as if startled you’d asked. "Oh! Jamie. Her name’s Jamie."

Your blood turned to ice.

Jamie.

That was your toxic ex's name.

Your fingers tightened around your biceps. A coincidence. It had to be. Jamie wasn’t exactly an uncommon name. But the prickle crawling up your spine refused to settle.

Talia, oblivious, was already pulling out her phone, the blue sleeve of her blouse slipping slightly as she swiped across the screen. "She’s got this ridiculous aesthetic going on—like, dark academia meets cottagecore? Here, I’ll show you her Insta—"

The screen spun toward you.

And there she was.

Jamie Aarons.

Her familiar smirk, those cunning dark eyes, her brown wolf-cut framing her face just so—every pixel oozed the same calculated charm that had once ensnared you. Your stomach lurched. No. No. This wasn’t an accident. Jamie didn’t do accidents.

Talia’s smile faltered as she took in your expression. The light in her eyes dimmed, replaced with hesitant concern. Her voice was small. Confused. "...What’s wrong?"

The warnings had fallen on deaf ears. No matter how many times you'd tried to explain—how carefully you'd chosen your words, how earnestly you'd pleaded—Talia had remained stubbornly, infuriatingly hopeful.

"People change," she'd insisted that night, perched on the edge of your bed, her fingers twisting nervously in the fabric of her skirt. "Maybe she's not the same person you knew."

You'd wanted to argue. Wanted to tell her that people like Jamie didn't change, not really—that the kindness Talia saw was just another mask, another calculated performance. But the way Talia had looked at you—big green eyes brimming with quiet defiance, her jaw set in that rare, stubborn way—had left you with no choice but to relent.

Talia had beamed, pressing a quick, grateful kiss to your cheek before bounding off, already pulling out her phone—no doubt to text Jamie right then and there.

That had been two weeks ago.

Now, the midday sun beat down mercilessly as you trudged down the familiar stretch of sidewalk, grocery list clutched in your hand. Saturdays were sacred—the one evening Talia always reserved for you. Cooking together had become something of a ritual: choosing the recipe together early in the week, bickering playfully over spices, stealing bites of half-finished dishes as you waited for the timer to go off. This week’s menu—lemon garlic salmon—had been Talia’s pick, though you’d been the one to insist on fresh dill instead of dried.

The usual route to the grocery store was muscle memory by now. Past the sandwich shop with its perpetually flickering neon sign, past the jewelry store where the elderly owner always waved through the glass, past the diner—

You froze mid-step.

Through the smudged window of the diner, bathed in the warm glow of retro lighting, sat Talia—her blonde hair catching the light as she laughed at something across the table. And there, leaning in with that infuriatingly confident smirk, was Jamie.

They were sharing a milkshake.

One straw. Two mouths.

Your stomach lurched.

Talia chose that moment to glance up, her eyes lighting up with recognition as she spotted you. She waved eagerly, beckoning you inside—completely oblivious to the way your fingers curled into fists at your sides.

Jamie turned.

Her dark eyes locked onto yours, and for a fraction of a second, something unreadable flickered across her face—a twitch of her brow, a tightening at the corner of her mouth—before it smoothed over into something far more dangerous: amusement.

The diner’s bell chimed obnoxiously as you pushed open the door, the scent of grease and syrup thick in the air.

"{{user}}!" Talia’s voice was bright, breathless. "What are the odds?"

Jamie didn’t stand. Didn’t even bother to feign politeness. Just tilted her head, that smirk never wavering as she drawled, "Hello."

It was icy. Deliberate.

Talia’s gaze darted between the two of you, her smile faltering. "Oh—right, you know each other." She bit her lip, fingers twisting around her straw. "Please don’t fight. You’re both… important to me."

Your jaw clenched. Important? Jamie?

Before you could even process the sheer audacity of that statement, Jamie leaned forward, propping her chin on her hand. "Oh?" she purred, her voice dripping with faux sweetness. "I’m important to you?"

Talia flushed pink, her shoulders lifting in a shy shrug. "Well—yeah?"

Jamie’s smirk deepened, her eyes sliding to you—just for a second—before returning to Talia. "Huh. You’re important to me too." A pause. "Very important."

Talia’s breath hitched, her giggle escaping like she couldn’t contain it.

"Oh!" Talia blinked, as if suddenly remembering you were still standing there. "Right, why were you passing by?"

The question stung more than it should have.

She forgot.

Every Saturday. Like clockwork. And she’d forgotten.

You swallowed the bitter taste in your mouth and reminded her—slowly, carefully—about the groceries. About the salmon. About your plans.

"Oh!" Talia’s face lit up again, her earlier excitement rushing back. "Right, right! The lemon garlic salmon! I’m so excited." She shooed you playfully. "We shouldn’t keep you. Go on, I’ll see you later!"

You forced a nod, turning on your heel before you could say something you’d regret.

But Jamie wasn’t done.

"Yeah," she called after you, her voice syrupy with false cheer. "See you around, {{user}}."

The past few months had been a slow unraveling—threads of your relationship with Talia loosening one by one, though you hadn’t wanted to admit it at first.

Jamie’s presence in Talia’s life had been a constant, gnawing worry, but against all your fears, nothing catastrophic had happened. No screaming matches, no sudden betrayals, no signs of Jamie’s venom seeping into Talia’s softness. If anything, Talia seemed… happier. Lighter. She’d gush about their library meetups, their shared obsession with obscure fantasy lore, the way Jamie always remembered how she took her tea.

"She’s just—really thoughtful, you know?" Talia had murmured one evening, curled against you on the couch, her fingers tracing idle patterns on your arm.

You hadn’t known. The Jamie you knew was meticulous, yes—but only when it served her.

Still, you’d bitten your tongue. Talia deserved friends. Deserved happiness. And if Jamie was—against all odds—genuinely trying to be better, then who were you to interfere?

But then the shifts started.

Small, at first.

Talia checking her phone mid-conversation, her thumbs flying across the screen before she’d catch herself and tuck it away with an apologetic smile.

Talia cutting your evenings short with flimsy excuses—"I’ve got an assignment due," "Professor moved up the deadline," "I’m just… really tired tonight."

Talia postponing plans. Canceling last minute. Leaving you on read.

That last one was the real red flag. Talia didn’t leave people on read. Ever. She was the type to send paragraph-long apologies if she took more than ten minutes to reply.

And then, this past week—radio silence. Messages unanswered. Calls ignored.

Today had been the breaking point.

4 PM. Talia’s last class ended at 3:45. She always texted you when she was heading home. Always.

But today—nothing.

Your first call went to voicemail. The second rang endlessly before cutting off.

Something was wrong.

You’d bolted from your apartment, sneakers slapping against pavement as you retraced Talia’s usual haunts—the diner with the strawberry milkshakes she loved, the arcade where she’d spend hours trying to beat the high score on Dance Dance Revolution, the overpriced furniture store she browsed just to sigh over rugs she’d never afford.

Nothing.

The library—her spot—was deserted except for a few studious strangers.

What if she was sick? What if she’d collapsed somewhere? What if—

Her apartment building loomed ahead, its brick facade bathed in the golden glow of late afternoon. Your hands shook as you fumbled under the doormat for the spare key she’d entrusted to you months ago—"Just in case," she’d said, pressing it into your palm with a smile.

The key turned with a soft click.

You eased the door open, wincing at the creak of hinges.

The apartment smelled like her—vanilla and old books and the lavender detergent she used on her sheets. Your socked feet barely made a sound as you crept down the hallway, heart hammering against your ribs.

And then—

A noise.

A gasp.

High-pitched. Breathless.

Your blood turned to ice.

Another sound—wet, rhythmic, filthy—followed by a whimper so broken it didn’t even sound like her.

No.

No no no—

The bedroom door was ajar. Just a sliver. Just enough.

Talia sprawled across the rumpled sheets, her body glistening with sweat, her blonde hair fanned out like a halo. She was bare—every soft curve, every freckle, every inch of skin you’d only ever touched with reverence—now exposed, claimed, by—

Jamie.

Jamie, perched between Talia’s thighs like a predator, her fingers buried knuckle-deep inside her, her mouth latched onto Talia’s left breast with a hunger that bordered on violent.

"Mmm. You like that, baby?" Jamie purred, her voice thick with triumph.

Talia’s back arched off the bed, a broken moan tearing from her throat. "Ngh—y-yes, Jamie! D-don’t stop—"

Jamie laughed—a dark, delighted sound—and curled her fingers just so, wrenching a guttural cry from Talia that you’d never heard before. Not with you. Not ever.

"These beautiful tits," Jamie murmured, tongue circling Talia's nipple before biting gently. "You love when I do this, huh?"

Talia’s hips jerked, desperate. "Fuck—harder, please—"

Jamie’s smirk was a knife twisting in your gut. "Aw, you love me that much?"

Talia whined—actually whined—her fingers clawing at the sheets. "I—I love you so so much."

Jamie’s hand yanked free, leaving Talia clenching around nothing, her cry of protest sharp in the air.

"More than {{user}}?"

The world stopped.

Talia didn’t hesitate.

"Yes." Her voice was raw, wrecked, certain. "So much more."

Jamie’s laugh was pure venom. "Good girl."

Her fingers plunged back in, hard, and Talia’s entire body bowed off the bed, her scream muffled by Jamie’s mouth crashing onto hers.

"Let me show you how much better I can make you feel," Jamie growled against her lips.

Talia sobbed, her thighs trembling, her nails raking down Jamie’s back. "I—I LOVE YOU!"

Write your own scenario: