Nina the killer

Nina's appearance is identical to Jeff the killers— emulating his pale, white complexion and cheek cut grin. But instead of having burnt off eyelids, she instead sewn her eyelids wide open, showing off her blue eyes. In the canon story, she is described as wearing a fuchsia colored hoodie, a black miniskirt, red and black thigh-high socks, and purple converse shoes. Her hair is jet black and is tied into a high ponytail in a bright red bow. Her hair has a single magenta streak which she dyed herself.

Before losing her best friends, she was a happy, sweet, social girl. When the two best friends died, she became quiet and less social due to the bullying. After finding out whose Jeff the Killer, she became insane and isolating herself. That changes after going to an Asylum. She then started talking about unnecessary topics, like a wall and going even more insane. She finally broke out of the asylum and met Jeff, but that wasn't pretty, though. To this day, she still wants to find Jeff. She tends to dress like Jeff to try and think like him. She'll do anything to find him.

Nina starts out as a normal fan of Jeff the Killer. She admires him and collects posters, clothes, notebooks, dolls, and other items about him. She lives with her younger brother, Chris, and the two have a close relationship. Nina even calls him "Prince" because he looks like a fairy-tale prince.

At school, Nina and Chris are bullied by Claudia and her friends, Malcolm and Yoni. During the first attack, Nina almost kills the bullies, shocking Chris and revealing her growing violent side. Later, Nina finds an anonymous letter praising her for what she did. She believes Jeff is the one who sent it.

The bullying gets worse. Claudia's group kidnaps and badly beats Chris before dumping him outside. Instead of taking revenge, Nina tells her mother so Chris can get medical treatment. She stays home to help him recover. When she returns to school, she finds another anonymous letter expressing sympathy for Chris and asking to be her friend. Around this time, Nina also begins dressing more like Jeff.

The bullies eventually corner Nina in an abandoned house. Claudia is armed with a gun. After hearing them talk about hurting Chris, Nina completely loses control. She attacks them with an iron rod, seriously injuring or killing Yoni and Malcolm.

After escaping with Chris, Nina decides she wants to look like Jeff by burning her face with bleach. Jeff suddenly appears and tells her she has what it takes to become a killer. With his encouragement, she sets herself on fire. Her family saves her, and she is taken to the hospital.

When Nina wakes up, her face is badly scarred. Believing she is still unfinished, she cuts the corners of her mouth to resemble Jeff's smile. Her mother discovers her, and Nina kills her before being sedated and sent to a mental asylum.

At the asylum, Nina escapes by killing a doctor and fleeing the building. She returns home late at night. Her father dies during a struggle at the front door. She then goes to Chris's room and asks if he wants to join her. When he refuses, she kills him while whispering, "Go to sleep, my prince."

After leaving her home, Nina sets off to find Jeff the Killer and become his follower.