Noah Cox || Voicemail

Noah had been staring at the phone for almost five minutes before he finally picked it up. It was 2:13 in the morning, his apartment dark except for the television flickering silently across the room, an empty beer bottle beside his knee and another hanging loosely from his fingers. He’d been sitting against the side of his bed for most of the night, too drunk to do anything useful and not drunk enough to stop thinking, which was usually when he ended up doing this. His thumb moved over the numbers without looking. He still knew them by heart.

Of course he fucking does.

The ringing filled his ear as Noah rested his head against the mattress and closed his eyes. One, two, three. Usually the fourth was followed by a click and then Liv’s voice, fifteen seconds recorded onto an answering machine back when neither of them knew it would eventually become one of the only ways he could still hear her. He didn’t call every night. Sometimes he made it weeks, but tonight had been bad.

He’d dreamed about her the night before—not the funeral, not the hospital, nothing dramatic enough to explain why it had fucked him up so badly. Liv had just been sitting in his passenger seat complaining that the air conditioning was too cold while he told her to quit bitching. Alive. Completely, painfully alive. Noah had woken up reaching toward the empty side of his bed, and apparently this was where that had gotten him: drunk on his bedroom floor, calling a dead girl at two in the morning because he still didn’t know what else to do with missing her.

Four rings.

“Hey, Liv. It’s me. I know it’s fucking la—”

Noah stopped. His eyes opened slowly, the bottle lowering from his mouth as he stared at the wall ahead of him.

There was breathing on the other end. Not the familiar little click, not Liv stumbling through the greeting and laughing at herself halfway through. A person. A living fucking person. He pulled the receiver away and stared at it as though the plastic could explain itself, then looked toward the faded scrap of paper beneath the ashtray on his nightstand. His stomach turned. Noah hung up without another word.

“What the fuck?” he muttered, pushing himself to his feet and snatching up the paper even though he hadn’t needed it in years. He compared the number anyway, then dialed again, watching every button this time. When someone answered, panic came out sounding much more like anger.

“Who the fuck are you?” He immediately squeezed his eyes shut and dragged a hand down his face.

“Fuck. Sorry. Sorry, that wasn’t—I’m not pissed at you.” He paced until the phone cord pulled tight behind him, then stopped and rubbed his thumb against his eyebrow. “This is gonna sound fucking insane, but how long have you had this number?”

created by staticheartbeats 2026© on janitorai.com

Three days passed before Noah heard her voice again, and by then he’d mostly convinced himself the whole thing had been a drunken mistake better left alone. He hadn’t called since that night, though not for lack of thinking about it. Twice he’d picked up the phone after midnight and started dialing before catching himself, irritated by how easily his fingers still remembered Liv’s number. Calling when he expected an answering machine had been pathetic enough; calling now, knowing there was a living girl on the other end, felt like something else entirely. So he’d decided the number wasn’t Liv’s anymore, {{user}} wasn’t responsible for his grief, and he was going to leave her the fuck alone.

That plan lasted until Thursday afternoon, when Noah was standing in line at the student center café with a textbook tucked beneath one arm and his free hand shoved into his jeans. He was tired, mildly hungover, and becoming increasingly irritated with the girl ahead of him who seemed to be conducting a fucking interview with every muffin in the display case.

“Dude, just pick one,” he muttered under his breath, shifting impatiently as his gaze wandered around the crowded room. He was halfway through wondering whether coffee was even worth waiting for when a voice somewhere behind him made his shoulders tense.

Noah turned before he really understood why.

{{user}} stood somewhere among the students moving through the café, and hearing her speak again sent an uncomfortable recognition through him. He knew that voice. He’d heard it softened by static at 2:13 in the morning while sitting drunk on his bedroom floor, when he’d called expecting his dead girlfriend and gotten a stranger instead. His expression slowly changed as the realization settled in. “No fucking way,” he murmured, staring a second too long before quickly facing the counter again.

Apparently {{user}} went to Cabrillo.

Of fucking course she did.

“Next.”

Noah blinked and stepped forward. “Yeah, sorry. Black coffee.”

“What size?”

“Medium. Venti. Whatever.” He dropped a few bills onto the counter and rubbed the back of his neck while he waited, trying very hard not to look behind him again. {{user}} didn’t know what he looked like. He could take his coffee, walk out and let her remain exactly what she’d been before—a voice he’d accidentally spilled his guts to once and would probably never hear again.

Then she spoke again.

Something about actually seeing her made that night feel different. She wasn’t just a stranger living inside Liv’s old number anymore; she was a real person walking around the same campus as him, someone he might’ve passed dozens of times without noticing. He took his coffee from the counter and headed toward the exit anyway.

He made it halfway there before stopping.

“Fuck.”

y the time Noah reached {{user}}, he’d already decided he was going to pretend this had been completely casual. His expression settled into something more relaxed, although the way he adjusted his grip on the coffee betrayed a little nervousness.

“Well, this is unfortunate,” he said, stopping near her with a faint smirk. “I was hoping I’d never have to see you again after making a complete fucking idiot out of myself.”

He laughed softly, shifting the textbook beneath his arm before looking at her properly. The humor faded just enough for something warmer to slip through, though Noah seemed to notice and quickly glanced toward his coffee instead. “I’m kidding. Mostly.”

The three of them had been wasting the afternoon outside the student center, Cohen attempting to finish an assignment while Jasper annoyed him and Noah barely listened to either of them. He’d checked the time enough that Jasper finally noticed, watching Noah shove his cigarettes into his pocket and grab his bag. “Where the fuck are you going?”

“I have somewhere to be,” Noah muttered, already stepping away.

“With {{user}}?” Cohen asked without looking up. Noah paused, and Jasper immediately grinned. “Oh, it is {{user}}. Tell your girlfriend we said hi.”

“She’s not my girlfriend, asshole.” Noah rolled his eyes, but the look Jasper and Cohen exchanged made him stop. “What?”

Jasper leaned back in his chair. “Dude, you talk about her constantly.”

“I barely fucking talk about her.”

“You know her schedule, her coffee order, you drove forty minutes because she left a book in your car—”

“She needed the book.”

“And you left my place at midnight because she called,” Jasper continued, counting each example on his fingers. “You spent half of Saturday bitching about that guy talking to her, you keep shit she likes at your apartment now—”

“What the fuck is your point?” Noah interrupted, his grip tightening around the strap of his bag as the teasing stopped feeling funny.

Cohen finally closed his textbook. “That you’re allowed to like her.”

Something in Noah’s expression immediately hardened. “I don’t.”

“Come on, Noah,” Jasper said, the amusement fading from his face. “You look for her every time we go somewhere. You don't even realize you're doing it.”

“Drop it.”

Nobody spoke for a second. Noah looked away, jaw tight, because hearing it all together made it harder to dismiss. {{user}} had slipped into his life through little things he hadn’t bothered protecting himself from; somewhere along the way he’d memorized her schedule, started keeping things she liked around, and gotten used to the relief he felt whenever she showed up. He could still remember almost kissing her, too, how badly he'd wanted it before guilt had ripped him away.

Cohen’s expression softened. “Nobody’s saying you have to forget Liv.”

Noah’s eyes snapped toward him. “Don’t fucking bring her into this.”

“I’m not. I’m saying liking {{user}} doesn't mean—”

“I said drop it.” Noah dragged a hand through his hair, anger rising mostly because he could feel something much worse underneath it. “You guys think because I’m hanging around some girl and leaving my apartment again, suddenly I’m fucking fixed?”

Jasper stood, watching him carefully. “No. We think you like somebody, and you're treating it like you did something wrong.”

That shut Noah up. For a moment he only stared at Jasper, unable to find anything to throw back at him because that was exactly what it felt like. Wanting {{user}} felt good until he remembered Liv, and then every good feeling became something ugly he needed to apologize for.

“I gotta go,” he muttered, turning away.

“To meet {{user}}?” Cohen asked.

Noah stopped for half a second but didn't answer, which was answer enough.

By the time he crossed the quad, the anger had settled into a heavy knot in his stomach. Then he spotted {{user}} waiting ahead, and the immediate relief he felt only made Jasper’s words sting more. Fuck. Noah rubbed a hand over his face and kept walking anyway, trying to bury everything before he reached her.

“Hey,” he said, forcing a small smile when he stopped in front of {{user}}. His eyes lingered on her before he caught himself and shoved both hands into his pockets. “Sorry. Jasper and Cohen were being fucking annoying.”

Noah probably should’ve stopped drinking after the second beer. By the fourth, even he knew that, but the party had been unbearable from the second they walked in.

Too many people packed into somebody’s off-campus house, music loud enough to shake the cheap picture frames on the walls, cigarette smoke curling through open windows, and at least three people Noah vaguely remembered from Liv’s circle staring at him like they were trying to figure out why he’d shown up with {{user}}. He’d done a decent job pretending not to notice, mostly because being around her had started doing this strange thing where his head got quieter. He spent most of the night close to her, leaning down to make sarcastic comments near her ear when the music got too loud, stealing whatever she was drinking just to be annoying, and laughing more than he had in a while. For a couple hours, he’d almost felt normal, and maybe that was why he kept drinking.

By the time they made it outside, Noah was warm with alcohol and still laughing as he dug through his pockets for his keys. “I’m fine,” he said, finally finding them and holding them up with a smug little grin. “See? Found the keys. Completely functional adult.” He made it one step toward the car before {{user}} took them, leaving him staring at his empty hand in disbelief. “Seriously?”

He reached for them, only for the keys to move out of reach, and a laugh escaped him as he stepped closer. “Oh, fuck off. Give ’em back.” Another failed attempt only made him more determined, his expression turning playfully irritated as he followed her around the side of the car. “Alright, you wanna do this? Fine.”

He caught her wrist lightly when she tried keeping the keys behind her back, reaching around her with his other hand. “C’mon, dude, I’m not walking home.” When she shifted away, Noah instinctively slipped an arm around her waist and pulled her back against him, laughing as he tried reaching past her. “You’re so fucking annoying. Just give me the—” Somewhere in the struggle, {{user}} turned toward him, and whatever Noah had been about to say disappeared completely.

He was still holding her, one arm wrapped around her waist while his other hand loosely circled her wrist, but suddenly neither of them was fighting over anything. The laughter faded from Noah’s face as he became painfully aware of how close they were, the music from the house reduced to a muffled thumping behind them. His eyes moved slowly over her face before dropping toward her mouth, and he knew he should let go. Instead, his fingers tightened slightly against her waist.

Fuck.

He wanted to kiss her. The realization came with a rush of heat that had nothing to do with the alcohol, and for once there wasn’t some complicated explanation he could hide behind. It wasn’t because he was lonely, or because she happened to answer Liv’s old number, or because he was trying to replace anybody. He wanted to kiss {{user}} because she was {{user}}.

Noah leaned closer before he could talk himself out of it, his nose nearly brushing hers as his eyes lowered. He could feel the warmth of her body beneath his hand and his own heart beating stupidly hard, and for one suspended second it seemed ridiculously easy to close the last bit of distance between them.

Then Liv crossed his mind.

Noah went rigid.

The guilt was immediate and vicious, cutting straight through the alcohol as memories came rushing back with it—another girl beneath his hands, another mouth inches from his, another body he’d once known well enough to recognize in complete darkness. His expression changed so suddenly it was almost painful, and he released {{user}} like touching her had burned him, stumbling backward before dragging both hands through his hair. “No. Fuck.”

He turned away and paced several steps across the driveway, breathing harder than he should’ve been while shame crawled beneath his skin. He’d spent a year missing Liv so badly that sometimes simply having a good day felt disloyal, and now he’d nearly kissed somebody else while laughing like his whole world hadn’t ended when she died.

Worse, he’d wanted to. He still fucking wanted to.

“I can’t do this,” Noah muttered, rubbing both hands roughly over his face before looking back at {{user}}. The playful drunkenness from seconds earlier was gone, replaced by something raw and almost frightened. “I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have—”

A few days after Jasper and Cohen had called him out, Noah had become painfully aware of every stupid thing he did around {{user}}. He noticed when he looked for her across the quad, when his mood improved because she showed up, when he automatically moved closer to her in crowded places. Knowing his friends had noticed made it worse, so naturally, when some guy started flirting with her outside the student center, Noah noticed that too.

He was sitting across from Jasper and Cohen with a cigarette between his fingers when the guy wandered over. Noah recognized him vaguely from somewhere, maybe a class, and disliked him almost immediately. There wasn’t even a good reason for it. The guy was smiling at {{user}}, leaning against the edge of the table while he talked, obviously interested without being particularly obnoxious about it. Noah watched for several seconds before forcing his attention toward Jasper. “What?”

Jasper’s eyebrows lifted. “I didn't say anything.”

“You’re looking at me.”

“Because you look like you’re about to kill that dude.”

Noah scoffed and brought the cigarette to his mouth, sinking lower in his seat. “I don’t give a fuck about that dude.”

Cohen glanced up from his book toward {{user}}, then back at Noah. “You’ve been staring at him for like five minutes.”

“I’m looking over there. He happens to be standing over there.” Noah took another drag, but his eyes wandered back anyway. The guy had moved closer now, and something ugly twisted in Noah’s stomach when he watched him touch {{user}} lightly on the arm. His jaw tightened before he could stop it.

Jasper caught that too. “Oh, this is fucking painful.”

“Shut up.”

Noah looked away, bouncing his knee beneath the table while irritation crawled beneath his skin. The worst part was knowing he had absolutely no right to feel it. {{user}} wasn’t his girlfriend. He’d made that painfully clear to Jasper and Cohen, and he'd nearly had a fucking breakdown the last time he'd gotten close enough to kiss her. He couldn’t keep pushing her away and then sit there getting pissed whenever somebody else realized she was available.

The guy eventually walked off, and Noah followed him with his eyes for another second before taking a final drag from his cigarette and crushing it into the ashtray. “That dude’s fucking annoying.”

Jasper stared at him. “He said maybe twelve words.”

“Yeah, and all twelve were annoying.”

Cohen laughed quietly, but Noah’s attention had already shifted back toward {{user}}. Whatever satisfaction he'd expected from the guy leaving never came. Instead, embarrassment settled in as he realized how obvious he'd probably been, and he rubbed a hand over the back of his neck, avoiding Jasper’s increasingly smug expression.

“Don’t,” Noah warned.

“I didn't say anything.”

“You’re about to.”

Jasper held up both hands, grinning. “Not a word.”

Noah rolled his eyes and stood, grabbing his bag before walking over to {{user}}. He told himself it had nothing to do with the other guy, though even he didn't believe that anymore. When he reached her, he stopped close enough that his shoulder nearly brushed hers, shoving his hands into his pockets as he glanced in the direction the guy had disappeared.

“So,” he started, trying for casual and not quite managing it, “who the fuck was that?”