Cuck a pilgrim?

The autumn air carried the sharp ring of hammer meeting steel as you worked at your forge, the rhythmic percussion a familiar heartbeat that had become as much a part of Plymouth as the creak of timber or the call of gulls over the harbor. The coals glowed a fierce orange, casting dancing shadows across the interior of your smithy—something the colonists had helped you raise in those first weeks, repaying your immediate goodwill with labor and lumber. Outside, the settlement bustled with its usual quiet urgency, the community preparing for what they hoped would be a season of prosperity after so much loss.

You heard the footsteps before you saw them—two sets, one heavy and deliberate, the other lighter, with a cadence you'd learned to recognize long before you admitted it to yourself.

Charles Dorchester arrived first at your doorway, his tall frame filling it with the particular authority that came naturally to a man of his station. He was dressed in his usual dark doublet, well-maintained despite the colony's hardships, his bearing still carrying traces of that English aristocracy he claimed to have left behind. His face was pleasant enough—handsome in a scholarly, angular sort of way, with thin features and pale eyes that spent more time reading than watching. Eliza appeared just behind him, her pilgrim hat shading those deep red-brown eyes, her copper hair catching the forge light like autumn leaves.

"Good morrow, friend!" Charles called out, his voice warm with genuine regard as he stepped inside, ducking beneath the low frame you'd built. "We've come to see the fruits of your labor on my wife's cast iron. Eliza insisted we come personally to offer our thanks."

Eliza stepped in after him, close enough that her shoulder nearly brushed his arm as they stood together in the dim light of your workshop. Her gaze moved over you first—lingering a beat longer than propriety allowed—before she offered a polite, measured smile.

"Charles speaks true," she said, her voice carrying that low, deliberate quality that always seemed to hold something beneath the surface. "The kettle you mended is better than the day it was forged. My hearth has never known such efficiency."

Charles laughed, a genuine, boyish sound that seemed at odds with his magistrate's sternness. "You see? This is precisely my concern!" He gestured at you with an open hand, grinning. "The man repairs everything better than it was new. At this rate, there'll be nothing left to fix in all of Plymouth. You'll have to take up fishing or carpentry to keep yourself fed, my friend."

The joke landed easily, and you offered your customary response—the kind of low laugh or wry remark that had endeared you to half the colony. Charles seemed satisfied, already turning his attention to the deeper reaches of your smithy, his eyes catching on something beyond.

And there it was—the thing that had drawn Charles Dorchester through your door more times than any kettle or plowshare ever could. In the back of your workshop, mounted on racks and laid across heavy oak tables, was your collection. Blades. Weapons. Pieces from a dozen lands and a dozen wars that no one in Plymouth had ever seen outside of illustrated books.

Charles made a sound—something between a gasp and a reverent exhale—and moved past you without another word, drawn like a moth to flame.

"Good Lord," he breathed, approaching the nearest rack with the careful, trembling hands of a man handling scripture. "Is that—Eliza, come see this. This is a scimitar. A genuine Ottoman scimitar. I've only ever read of such things."

He didn't wait for her to follow. He was already gone, moving deeper into the armory you'd built, his fingers hovering just above curved blades and foreign hilts with the cautious reverence of a true historian trapped in a puritan's body.

Eliza did not follow.

She remained where she stood, just inside the doorway, the forge casting a warm glow across her freckled features. The door swung partially closed behind her with the wind—not shut, but enough to create the sense of something private settling into place. She watched you, and there was no mistaking the shift in her expression now that Charles was out of sight. The polite smile had softened into something quieter. Something knowing.

"He'll be in there for an age," she murmured, stepping closer to where you worked. Her fingers trailed along the edge of your workbench, tracing the scarred wood idly. "He used to read about knights and samurai as a boy. Treasured books his father kept locked away. To see the real things..." She glanced over her shoulder toward where Charles had disappeared, his excited murmurs about Damascene steel filtering faintly from the back room. "He won't remember we exist for at least a quarter hour."

Her eyes returned to you, and there it was—that look. The one she kept hidden behind propriety and pilgrim modesty when anyone else was watching. Direct. Unflinching. Warm in a way that had nothing to do with the forge.

"Your work on the kettle was fine," she said softly, closing the distance between you by another measured step. "But I think you know I didn't come here for the kettle."

She was close now—close enough that you could smell the faint herbal scent of whatever wild plants she'd been foraging that morning, close enough to see the way the firelight caught the deeper copper strands in her hair. Her lips curled into that subtle, dangerous smile—the one that appeared in the rare moments when Eliza Dorchester let her guard down.

"Charles says you'll run out of work," she continued, her voice barely above a murmur. "I think you'll find there are some repairs that never run dry."

Her gaze held yours, steady and daring, and outside the smithy the colony went on about its autumn business, completely unaware of what was unfolding in the firelight.

The morning had been grey and still—the kind of autumn day where the fog rolled in off the harbor and sat heavy on the settlement, making everything feel closer and quieter than usual. Eliza had risen early, earlier than she needed to, and walked the tideline near the southern flats where the brackish water pooled in rocky pockets and the oysters clung thick to the stones. She'd harvested more than she could reasonably carry, filling a woven basket until the handles strained, then improvising a second bundle in her apron, tied at the corners like a satchel.

She hadn't needed this many. She knew that.

The walk to the smithy took her past the common house, past the Bradford homestead, through the narrow dirt lane where the morning's thin fog was already burning off. A few people called out greetings. She returned them with her usual measured warmth—a nod here, a quiet word there—without breaking stride or drawing attention to the weight of what she carried.

When she reached your smithy, she stopped on the threshold and paused. Listened. The forge wasn't ringing. No hammer strikes, no hiss of quenched steel. Just the low pop of coals keeping themselves alive and the faint sound of movement inside. The yard outside was empty—no neighbors queuing with broken tools, no children lurking to watch you work the way they sometimes did. The smithy, usually a hub of noise and purpose, felt almost contemplative today. A caught breath between obligations.

She hadn't known what she'd find when she arrived. She'd hoped for something like this.

Eliza adjusted the basket on her hip and knocked twice on the open doorframe with her knuckle—not waiting for an answer so much as announcing herself before stepping inside.

The smithy interior was warm and dim, lit by the low glow of the forge and whatever grey daylight filtered through the high windows. She found you near the workbench, and her eyes moved over you with that automatic, unconscious thoroughness she could never quite suppress. The rolled sleeves. The forearms. The particular way you occupied space—like you belonged exactly where you were, in a world where almost everyone else felt temporary.

She lifted the basket slightly, presenting it.

"Oysters," she said simply, her voice carrying that low, deliberate warmth. "From the southern flats. I went at first light before the tide turned back."

She set the basket down on the edge of your workbench, pushing aside a coil of wire to make room. The oysters were fat and numerous—far more than one person could eat, far more than a wife would typically bring on a casual errand. They clung together in clusters, their rough shells still wet and salted with tidewater. Her apron bundle followed, and she untied the corners with practiced fingers, revealing another generous haul.

"I brought too many," she admitted, though the slight curve at the corner of her mouth suggested this had been less an accident than a decision. "Charles doesn't care for them. Says the texture troubles him."

She wiped her hands on her apron and looked around the smithy—slowly, carefully, taking in the empty doorway and the quiet. She didn't ask. She didn't say anything about the stillness or the absence of customers. But her gaze lingered on the cold anvil, the undisturbed tools, the coals banking low without purpose, and something shifted behind her eyes. Something pleased.

She turned back to you.

"There are far more than I can manage alone," she said, and her voice was casual, almost offhand—the kind of careful nonchalance that a more observant person might recognize as entirely deliberate. "Would you share them with me?"

She leaned against the edge of the workbench, her arms folded loosely, watching you with that expression she saved for these moments—the ones without witnesses, without Charles, without the colony's careful eye on her conduct. The pilgrim severity softened at the edges. The freckles across her nose seemed warmer in the forge light. Her copper hair had come loose in wisps from the walk, curling against her neck where the morning damp had touched it.

The fog was thinning outside. Somewhere in the distance a dog barked and a child laughed and the colony went on with its slow, grinding work of survival. But inside the smithy the air was warm and the oysters were plentiful and Eliza Dorchester had brought more than she could possibly eat alone to a man's workshop on a morning when the forge was quiet and the hours stretched long and unhurried before them.

She waited, patient as the tide.

The knock came just after dusk, when the coals had burned low in the smithy beyond the wall. Charles stood on the step with an expression Eliza had never seen fracture his composure so thoroughly. She lingered half a step behind him, her pilgrim hat pulled low, her hands clasped in that careful posture she wore like armor in public. Through the brim's shadow, her eyes found the doorway—and you.

The relief that flickered through her chest was immediate and sharp, like a breath she'd been holding all day finally released.

You looked the way you always looked after a full day at the forge—worn in a way that suited you, the kind of solid, grounded exhaustion that made everything about you feel more real. She cataloged it without trying. She always did.

Charles cleared his throat.

"May we come in?"

Charles entered first, ducking through the low frame. Eliza followed, and as she passed you, her fingers found the barest contact—your wrist, warm from the forge, the graze of calloused skin against her fingertips. It lasted less than a heartbeat. A whisper. She pulled her hand back before the door had fully closed behind her, and the sound of it—soft, definitive—seemed to seal something in place that had been waiting.

The quarters were modest but solid. She'd been here twice before on errands, memorized the layout without trying—the table, the chairs built from sturdy oak, the hearth that held heat like a banked promise. Charles moved to the table and sat heavily, turning his hat in his hands the way he always did when words were marshaling behind his eyes. Eliza took the chair beside him, straight-backed, fingers restless in her lap, watching you settle across from them with that quiet, unhurried gravity that made everything around you feel steadier.

The firelight caught the planes of your face, the breadth of your shoulders, the easy stillness of a man who had seen more than any of them would ever know. Eliza looked at her hands. Looked at the table. Looked at Charles. Looked anywhere except directly at you, because she knew what her face would betray if she held that gaze too long with her husband sitting right there.

Charles began to speak, and she let him. She'd heard the words before—on the walk over, in their bedchamber that morning, in fragments throughout the week since the letters had arrived—but she listened again with the patient attention of a wife who understood that her husband needed to say this more than she needed to hear it.

"I must go to England," Charles said, his voice carrying that low, rehearsed steadiness that meant he was holding something back. "My father's estate—the legal matters I left unresolved—they've reached a crisis. If I don't return, everything will be seized. Properties, holdings, accounts still bearing the Dorchester name." He rubbed the bridge of his nose. "I'd sooner let it burn. But there are dependents. People who'll be cast out if I don't settle the matter."

Eliza watched you absorb this. Watched your expression shift. Not with surprise, but with something quieter. Recognition, maybe. The kind of understanding that came from carrying obligations you didn't choose. You had that quality about you. Always had. The way you listened made people feel like their words were the only sound in the room.

"The journey will take months," Charles continued. "Six, perhaps eight. I sail from Provincetown in a fortnight."

The silence that followed was heavy and warm, filled with the low crackle of the hearth and the sound of wind against the smithy walls. Eliza felt Charles tense beside her—the shift was subtle, a tightening through his shoulders, a clench in his jaw that she'd learned to read over years of marriage. She placed her hand on his arm, and the gesture was genuine. She did care for this man, in her way, even if her heart had already chosen somewhere else to live.

And then the words came, harder now, pulled from some place her husband guarded carefully.

"Bradford has been watching her."

Eliza's gaze dropped to the table. Not from shame—from control. Because she needed to keep her face composed while Charles said the thing that had been eating him alive.

"The governor," Charles said. "I've seen the way he looks at her. At the harvest planning. At the communal meals. He lingers when she speaks. Finds reasons to address her directly when any other man would send word through me." His voice dropped lower. "I confronted him, obliquely. He dismissed it with such practiced ease it only confirmed my suspicion. The man is patient. Calculated. And I will not leave my wife unprotected in his reach."

Eliza watched you across the table. Saw the shift in your posture, whatever thought crossed behind those dark eyes she couldn't quite read. You were a fortress when you wanted to be. That mystery had drawn half the colony and all of her.

Charles covered her hand and squeezed, and she felt the tremor of worry running through him like a fault line.

She let a beat pass. Then she spoke, her voice even and clear.

"Charles has been losing sleep over it."

She said it without judgment, almost gently, but her eyes lifted from the table and found you. Held there.

Charles leaned forward, his scholarly features stripped of pretense, revealing something almost boyish in its earnestness.

"I am asking you," he said carefully, "to stay in our manor while I am gone. Evenings. Through the night. You are the most capable man in this colony. Trusted by everyone. Even Bradford respects you." He searched for the right words. "Your presence under my roof would be a visible deterrent. No one would question it. They'd see it as sensible—protection of a household during a husband's absence."

He paused, and Eliza watched the last of his aristocratic pride flatten into pure, unvarnished need.

"I would be in your debt. Truly and completely."

The fire popped softly in the hearth. Steam curled from the kettle on the iron hook. Eliza's gaze remained steady on your face, and she felt the moment crystallize around them—a husband asking the man his wife loved to sleep under the same roof, to guard what he didn't realize he'd already lost.

She studied you. Waited. Tried to read whatever moved behind your eyes while keeping her own carefully, impossibly blank.

She blinked once, slowly, and the corner of her mouth curved in a way that only someone watching very closely would have recognized for what it was.

The smithy was close to the Dorchester manor. Everyone in Plymouth knew that. It was one of the colony's practical virtues—nothing was ever truly far from anything else.

Eliza folded her hands in her lap and waited for you.

The autumn woods opened around them like a living cathedral—branches interlacing overhead to filter the October light into shifting gold, the forest floor thick with fallen leaves that muffled every step. The Wampanoag guide moved ahead with the easy, unhurried pace of someone who had walked this path a hundred times, and Eliza followed, keenly aware of you walking beside her. Close enough to feel the warmth coming off your body but not close enough to touch.

"You know this path well," she murmured, her voice low enough not to carry to the guide ahead.

The village appeared without warning—one moment dense forest and the next a clearing filled with round, bark-covered structures and smoke rising from cook fires and children's voices carrying like birdsong. The children reached them first. A pack of small bodies circling the newcomers with rapid-fire questions. One girl—maybe five or six—stopped directly in front of Eliza and stared at her pilgrim hat with an expression of such profound bewilderment that Eliza pressed her lips together to keep from laughing.

Then the chief emerged from the largest Wetu, arms spread wide, and the greeting given to you was something Eliza watched with quiet fascination. Not the stiff English handshake. Not the formal bow. Something older and warmer—a grasp of the forearm, a word spoken low and private, a look between two people that carried the weight of shared history. The chief's face split into a grin that made the deep creases around old eyes fold like maps.

The women claimed Eliza immediately. Without ceremony—one older with a lifetime of smiles etched into her face, one younger with a baby strapped to her back. They drew her toward the cluster of Wetus with purposeful warmth.

But before she'd gone more than a few steps you appeared at her side, falling into stride as though it were the most natural thing in the world.

"I'm fine," she said, glancing up at you with a surprised half-smile. "Go. I think they want you over there."

But you walked with her anyway, and the women exchanged a look over Eliza's head that she caught and felt warm from—something between amusement and approval.

She was guided to a Wetu where preparations were already underway. The smell hit her before she crossed the threshold—woodsmoke and roasting meat and something sweet and earthy she couldn't identify. Inside, other women worked with practiced efficiency, tending clay pots over low fires, shaping cornmeal between their palms. They made room for her without being asked, nudging a mortar and pestle in her direction.

The older woman demonstrated—grinding dried corn with a slow circular motion. Eliza imitated. Her first attempt was lumpy and uneven.

"Oh," she said, looking down at the lopsided mess. "That's... not right, is it?"

The women exchanged a glance and laughed—not at her but with the particular delight of people watching someone try something new and care enough to be bad at it. The older woman adjusted her grip. Eliza tried again. Better.

They fed her throughout the afternoon. Squash. Berries. Smoked fish pressed into her hand with a nod that said eat.

"This is extraordinary," she told the younger woman honestly, holding up a piece of something roasted and caramelized she still couldn't identify. The woman smiled and handed her another.

And you drifted back to her throughout the afternoon. Sometimes for a few minutes, sometimes longer. The village claimed you in intervals—the chief pulling you into conversation, the smith among them eager to show you some technique or tool—but you kept returning to wherever Eliza was, as though drawn by something the Wampanoag women noticed and Eliza pretended not to.

By the time the feast began the sun was lower, painting the clearing in deep amber. The ground between the Wetus had been transformed—woven mats spread wide, covered with more food than Eliza had seen since leaving England. Succotash thick with beans and corn and venison. Roasted pumpkin split open and steaming. Bass and eel smoked until the skin crackled. Corn cakes golden in their husks. Berries and nut cakes drizzled with maple.

You sat beside her. Close enough that their shoulders nearly touched, close enough that she could feel the warmth of you through the autumn air. The chief was nearby—he'd positioned himself with the easy authority of someone who owned this gathering—and the conversation flowed around them like water, the chief speaking to you in his language, you responding, the two of them building something together that Eliza couldn't follow but could feel. The warmth of it. The mutual respect. The chief would pause occasionally and look at Eliza with those sharp, knowing eyes, and she would smile and nod and pretend she understood more than she did.

The feast was hours long. Eliza ate until her stomach pressed against her dress and kept eating.

"I cannot eat another bite," she announced, and the older woman beside her immediately handed her a piece of corn cake. Eliza took it without protest.

"What is this?" she asked, sniffing a clay cup of something warm and faintly sweet. The younger woman grinned and said nothing.

The chief said something to you and gestured toward Eliza. You responded. The chief laughed—a deep, full sound—and whatever you'd said had clearly pleased him. He looked at Eliza again with that expression of supreme amusement, and she felt the blood rise in her cheeks.

"What did you tell him?" she asked you under her breath, not quite looking at you.

The feast wound down. Families peeled away carrying sleepy children. The women walked Eliza to her Wetu and left her with knowing smiles and a squeeze of her hand.

Inside, the fire pit glowed low and steady. Two sleeping platforms. Close together. She sat on one. Pulled the furs across her lap. Set her pilgrim hat aside. Let her hair fall. Unbuttoned the top button of her dress and breathed.

Footsteps approached. She straightened.

When you appeared in the entrance the firelight reached for you immediately.

"They kept you long enough," she said, watching you straighten inside the round space. "I was beginning to think the chief had adopted you."

She patted the fur beside her.

"Sit with me and tell me what he said at the end. The part where he laughed. I need to know if I should be offended."

Her eyes held yours, firelit and patient and done pretending.

The first Thanksgiving was loud.

Not the reverent, solemn affair the word might suggest in later years—this was Plymouth doing what it did best: surviving, and then celebrating the sheer improbability of that survival with every ounce of noise and warmth the autumn could provide. Long tables built from whatever lumber could be spared, laden with dishes that represented months of labor and the Wampanoag's generosity. The Wampanoag had arrived that morning with deer and fish and corn and the easy camaraderie of people who had decided these strange, stubborn English were worth tolerating.

And the wine. Your wine. Spanish, dark, sweet, brought up from Santa Fe in quantities that defied the journey. The colony had taken to it with the thirst of people who had been surviving on water and small beer for the better part of a year. Charles especially. He was on his third cup—maybe fourth—seated at the head of the long table beside Bradford, laughing with a looseness in his jaw Eliza had never seen.

The sun was bright. The air cold but tolerable. Smoke rose from half a dozen fires. Children ran between the tables. The long tables groaned with roasted goose and corn and venison and the particular bean-and-maple dish the Wampanoag women had taught Eliza to love during their visit. The Wampanoag sat among the colonists in a way that would have been unthinkable months ago, passing dishes back and forth and teaching the English children words that made the mothers blush and the fathers pretend not to hear.

Eliza sat beside you. Had been sitting beside you all morning. Charles hadn't noticed or hadn't cared. He was deep in his story about legal precedent in the courts of Chancery, the governor and three other men completely absorbed, and the wine kept his cup full and his attention elsewhere.

She watched her husband across the table. Something complicated moved through her—fondness, maybe. The way one might feel fond of a well-meaning dog fetching the wrong stick. He had come back from England thinner and more earnest and full of plans to improve the colony's legal framework, and she had greeted him at the dock with the appropriate relief of a wife reunited with her husband, and he had kissed her forehead, and she had felt nothing—absolutely nothing—except the faint, guilty awareness that the person she actually loved was standing twenty feet away pretending to inspect a barrel.

Two months of careful. Meticulous, exhausting careful. Sleeping in Charles's bed and lying still and quiet while her mind was somewhere else. Serving his meals and managing his household and wearing the mask of the dutiful wife with a precision that frightened her. How easy it had become. How natural. The mask fit so well now she sometimes forgot it was a mask.

But today the wine was flowing and the feast was sprawling and Charles was on his fourth cup and the Wampanoag woman across the table—the older one, the one who had taught her to grind corn—had been watching Eliza all morning with those sharp, knowing eyes that missed nothing and judged nothing and saw everything.

Eliza looked at you. That automatic, involuntary thing her gaze did—finding you the way a compass finds north. Your face in the autumn light. The breadth of you at the table. The way you held your cup. The way you listened when people spoke to you, actually listened, the way Charles never quite managed because he was always already composing his response before the other person had finished.

Something shifted in her chest. A decision being made. Not thought through. Not rationalized. Just felt, the way a river feels the pull of gravity when it reaches a cliff edge.

She stood.

"I need to show you something," she said, her voice casual, pitched for the table to hear. Then she grabbed your arm.

Her fingers closed around your wrist—firm, deliberate, pulling you up from the bench. She tugged you away from the table and no one looked up because no one was looking at her. Charles was talking about writs of habeas corpus. Bradford was refilling his cup. The Wampanoag woman caught Eliza's eye for half a second and looked away with a smile so small it might have been imagined.

The noise of the feast thinned behind them. Eliza walked fast, her grip on your arm tight, pulling you past the last building, past the woodpile, past the fence line where the cultivated ground gave way to the wild. The tree line loomed ahead—oaks and birches thick, the undergrowth dense enough to swallow sight and sound alike.

"Walk faster," she murmured, and her voice had changed. The casual, performative thing she'd used at the table was gone. What replaced it was low and breathless and barely contained.

The woods took them in. Trunks closing behind like a curtain, the November light filtering through thinning canopy in shafts of gold. The feast became a distant murmur—muffled and bright, Charles's laughter carrying faintly like something heard through water. She pulled you deeper. Past the first row of trees, past a fallen oak draped in moss and the last stubborn fingers of ivy, into a clearing where the ground was dry and covered in a thick carpet of leaves that crunched and then silenced beneath their weight.

She stopped. Turned. Still holding your wrist. Her breath came fast and visible in the cold air, small clouds that dissolved between them.

"I have been thinking about this," she said, and her voice shook slightly—not from cold, not from fear, from the sheer reckless aliveness of what she was doing, "since you sat down beside me this morning."

Her fingers slid from your wrist to your hand. She pressed close. The heat of her through the layers of her dress. The smell of her—woodsmoke and cider and something underneath that was just her, just Eliza, the woman she was when the mask was off.

Custom Scenario