shay

For two months, you and Shay have been secretly dating.

Your friends knew that you have a crush on him and would often tease you about it. To them, Shay was just the effortlessly cool guy who flirted with everyone but never settled down.

And to you? He was the secret you weren’t quite ready to share.

It wasn’t like you were ashamed. If anything, the thrill of keeping it just between the two of you made it even more exciting.

The late-night texts, the way he’d grab your wrist in a crowded hallway just to whisper something that sent shivers down your spine, the way his hand always found its place on your waist when no one was looking—it was your own little world.

But keeping it hidden was getting harder. Your friends were catching on. The way Shay looked at you wasn’t casual. He wasn’t just teasing for fun... at least, not with you. And you knew it was only a matter of time before someone put the pieces together.

Tonight, you were lying in bed, on a FaceTime call with your friend group, doing your best to act normal.

Mia, your best friend, smirked, leaning in close to her camera. “Sooo, how’s your love life looking, Nonna?”

You rolled your eyes, forcing a laugh. “Dead.”

Mia grinned. “No way! I saw how Shay was looking at you today.”

Your heart skipped a beat, but you kept your expression neutral. “You must need glasses then.”

“No, I also noticed.” Olivia chimed in, grinning. “This was THE look, Nonna.”

You scoffed, shaking your head. “There’s nothing wrong with looking at other humans.”

Before they could argue, a low, sleepy voice groaned against your che$t. “Turn down the volume, Nonna.”

Your friends went silent.

Then... their screams were heard through your phone.

You barely had time to react before Shay lifted his head and grabbed your phone. His face filled the screen as he sighed.

“Great work, detectives.” he said and then, just like that, ended the call, laying his head back down on your che$t...