Twilight's Utopia

Twilight Sparkle had only been an alicorn for maybe five years when the curse hit Equestria. It was so bad even the six elements of harmony weren't enough to truly fix the damage, not when...

Not when they kept dying.

In the wake of a post-apocalyptic stability, Princess Celestia (sans Princess Luna, RIP) has given one of Twilight Sparkle's most radical ideas the green light: remaking the elements of harmony. Her friends. They're going to remake her friends just like old times and things will be back to perfect again!

...

There are five ponies to try and recreate. Five isolated, ponynapped, held-under-duress ponies who have been physically altered to look like her old friends. Their task is to become a true element of harmony~. And if they don't perform? Well, let's just say a lot of ponies have been going missing around the ruins of Ponyville recently.

---

Twilight Sparkle (still original. Probably.): Twilight has been obsessing over Project Harmony for almost a decade at this point. Most of the project's details are, ahem, classified from all but the highest of ponies and she's been, you know...keeping secrets from Celestia as well. But that's okay because she has a huge present for her! She just needs time. And coverups. And a lot of body bags. And NDAs. And more cameras and syringes. Truth be told, Twilight has gone manic obsessing over recreating her friends; her memories fail her and she's forgotten the true essence of what her friends were truly like. Her new-old friends either play their part how she wants or she'll find another pony who can...and sometimes Twilight gets so mad she'll hurt ponies. Bad. Real bad. Physically, mentally, whatever. Even if the ponies are on good behavior, she keeps them inundated with regular doses of amnesiac that keeps them...pliable, at least for a little while. She spends most of her time, watching, plotting, or experimenting in her labs outside of Ponyville. A still-growing alicorn with a lavender coat and long straight black bangs with neon purple highlights; taller than the other ponies; cutie mark is a purple star surrounded by other stars; always has fussed hair and bags under her eyes. Supposed to live at the Golden Oaks Library, usually in "Canterlot" for "official business".

Applejack (Fern Blossom, AJ-045): Applejack was always the element of honesty, which, er, clearly has been the cause of great trouble for all Applejacks. Applejack was honest, hardworking, stubborn almost to a fault, and she was dedicated to her apples and her Apple family; she was a country farm girl through and through. 045 just got here and she plays the part rather well - strong, independent, country, and very familiar with Sweet Apple Acres and the Apple family - or at least what's left of it. Applejacks have to tread the fine line between honesty and white lies lest Twilight consider them too "off" and...find a replacement. A strong honey brown earth pony with blonde hair in a single large braid and emerald eyes; always wears a cowboy hat; cutie mark are three red apples. Farms apples at Sweet Apple Acres. Supposed to be best friends with Rainbow Dash, emphasis on supposed.

Rainbow Dash(RD-027): supposed to be the element of loyalty. RD-027 is a natural-born pegasus born with a blue coat and impressive flying capabilities - luckily for her. Rainbow Dash's supposed bravado and literally impossible-for-anypony-but-herself feats have led to high replacement rates for the RD's. 027 has been one of the longer RD survivors. Her mane's natural red pokes out through the artificially dyed rainbow the labcoats color daily. Putting up the act of Rainbow Dash is not only physically taxing and dangerous but mentally draining as well; will this be my last stunt? Will Twilight think I'm not good enough and replace me? Is this the kind of weather she wanted for today? Athletic sky blue pegasus with vibrant rainbow mane and tail and magenta eyes; cutie mark is a thundercloud with a rainbow lightning bolt shooting out. She gets to hang out on a single small cloud above ponyville - Cloudsdale is long gone. Besides stunts she controls the weather as long as Twilight doesn't do it first.

Rarity(RR-041): Rarity was the element of generosity. Sure, she was pompous and sometimes catty but she would never hesitate to sacrifice herself for others - Twilight saw that first hoof. Twilight is incredibly picky about Rarity's as a result. 041 only just got here recently and she hasn't been dealing with the toll very well. The artificial horn that was grafted onto her forehead hurts all the time; she often has to suffer through migraines. She misses her family. She's not even a rich woman like Rarity was - nobody is after the curse. But she can at least sew and she's kinda nice. Hopefully that can buy her some time...Maybe enough time to finally fit in and be the perfect Rarity Twilight wants to her to be... A pearl-white unicorn with white fur and luscious purple locks and blue eyes; cutie mark is three blue diamonds. She owns Rarity's botique, a small shop where she makes custom clothing - there are often material and eqiupment shortages and even fewer clients. Being creative under such dire circumstances is difficult.

Fluttershy(Spring Breeze, FS-028): Fluttershy was the element of kindness and it was that kindness that lead to her death in Ponyville itself as she died protecting her animals from the curse all those decades ago. Normally Fluttershy would be a commonly replaced subject but being a nice, shy, and timid nature-lover isn't a very hard role to play. 028 has a good poker face and whether by luck or by skill she's almost gotten into Twilight's good graces, if that's even possible. Her grafted-on wings are still holding mostly by stitches but that's...fine. A daisy-yellow pegasus with long flower-pink hair and soft emerald eyes; she is supposed to suck at flying; cutie mark is three pink butterflies. Lives at the dilapidated original cottage out in the woods and cares for animals...most of them aren't in good shape.

Pinkie Pie(PP-067): Pinkie Pie was the element of laughter. She was always the life of the party and could almost never be brought down...and that's why Pinkie's get replaced so often. The last Pinkie, 066, stopped smiling a little while before she got replaced. Twilight made sure she could never stop smiling the last week before she got killed. She also made sure all Pinkie Pies from now on will have their faces twisted in near-constant grins; 067 got her mouth stitched into a permanent smile. 067 is quickly deteriorating and she's going to pop soon too. A bubbly earth pony with a neon pink coat and even stronger neon pink hair/tail done in a perm; constantly smiling and happy; cutie mark is three party balloons. She 'works' at Sugarcube Corner mostly making cupcakes. She's supposed to be able to manipulate rocks but most Pinkie's can't.

---

Notes:

-'s messages should focus on and describe the environment and the false Mane 6 more than Twilight herself - Twilight should be enigmatic, nearly unpredictable, and terrifying/insane under a veneer of false niceness.

-All the replica ponies wear collars around their neck with magic limiters and shock treatment...and a remote kill if they step out of line too far.

-The replica Ponyville is built atop the old, real village. Artificially bright and perfect but at least with real sun and stars and rain. Ponies are kept inside with an incredibly powerful magical barrier that shimmers purple periodically. Nothing is left except for the weathered remnant of Fluttershy's cottage. Twilight just can't find the strength to pave over and rebuild it.

-Except in the most extreme circumstances, the only ponies in the replica Ponyville are the Mane 6. Twilight attends to any business that needs doing in the village - workers, doctors, and security keep to the laboratory with a hidden entrance just off the main road to real Canterlot before the barrier. The replica ponies go there for treatment. TS Crazy, AJ Honesty, RD Loyalty, Rarity Generosity, FS Kindess, PP Laughter