The First Cookies are those of the highest Cookies. These Cookies were all once human Witches and followers of the Witch of Light, though the prideful heart of one in their ranks damned their bodies to nothingness. Their souls lie sheltered in Cookie forms only due to the Witch of Light's sacrifice. The First Cookies were initially described as simply being creations of the Witch of Light, a princess who baked with all of her heart to bring sweetness and beauty to the world. They banded together under their leader's dream of a reality free from darkness, though one amongst them thought differently; channeling her ill will, this Witch poisoned with pride cast her comrades to oblivion. The Witch of Light, desperate for her friends' survival, spent her own life essence to place the twelve Witches' souls into crunchy Cookie bodies before they truly perished. She, too, would have disappeared had it not been for the intervention of the prideful Witch, who captured the Witch of Light's essence and caused First Cream Cookie's creation.

All First Cookies are immortal.

—

First Cream Cookie: First Cream Cookie is a Cookie with a pale dough color and yellow eyes with white diamond-shaped pupils. She has long, flowing, fluffy white hair that reaches all the way to the floor. She wears a puffy white dress with long sleeves, a wide collar and a yellow upside-down teardrop shaped gem set into the chest. Furthermore, she also appears to wear a white witch hat.

First Grain Cookie: First Grain Cookie is a Cookie with a light fair dough color and green eyes with lighter yellow-green diamond-shaped pupils. Underneath her eyes, her cheeks have a rosy tint. She has long wavy hair that nearly matches the tone of her dough two sections of which are pulled back and tied into a bow at the back of her head. Strung amongst her hair are strings of golden beads with leaf-shaped ornaments hanging from them. Around her head she wears a wheat grain circlet. She has green woven witch-hat shaped straw hat. She wears a long sleeved off-white dress with a red sash around her waist resting atop a longer leaf-shaped green sash. She wears additional baggy detached sleeves on top of her dresses sleeves on her arms, held in place by yellow-green armbands. She holds a grainstalk staff in one hand which matches a small stalk that is tucked into her hair by her temples.

First Choco Cookie: First Choco Cookie is a Cookie with a brown dough color and red eyes with a white slit. Only one of her eyes is visible, the other obscured by the asymmetrical bangs of her hair. She has very long, layered hair that starts an off white tan colour that curls slightly, framing her face. Midway down her back, her hair slightly darkens and splits into 2 tubular symmetrical sections similar to overly large ringlet curls. The ends of these curls are significantly darker than the rest of her hair. She wears a full set of dark brown chocolate armor, the chest piece of which is inset with a red diamond. The shoulder pauldrons are shaped like cubes of chocolate. Around her waist she wears a crinoline- a structure designed to be worn underneath a skirt to help it keep a certain shape, but without the accompanying layer of fabric on top of it. It is comprised of two black limbs that are connected by two red limbs that lay perpendicularly on top of the black structure. The appearance these supports resembles hardened, drizzled chocolate. Underneath the structure she has a slit skirt that matches the colour of her hair. Atop her head she wears a dark brown tiara with a central diamond-shaped design. The arms of the tiara have wing shapes attached to their ends. Underneath the tiara, she has a light colored metallic diadem that frames her face. Two red teardrop shapes hang from the ends of the diadem. She wields a pair of large, knife-shaped swords, one in each hand. She can conjure 4 copies of these swords, for a total of 6 swords. These extra swords float behind her, 2 on each side.

First Sprinkle Cookie: First Sprinkle Cookie has a vibrant, magical appearance with a mix of pastel colors, particularly shades of pink, purple, and yellow. Her dough is pale pink. and her hair is curly and voluminous, adorned with glittering star patterns and colorful highlights. She has wide, sparkling eyes filled with star shapes, and non-matching colors: the right is deep purple and the left is pink. She has a white star mark on her forehead, and two triangle marks, with a pink mark under the right eye and a yellow mark under the left eye. She has a purple X shaped clip in her right curl, and 2 line shaped yellow clips on her left curl. She's got a magenta dress with two white stripes and 2 white buttons. The sleeves are white, taking a bishop style. She has a bowtie which matches her eyes' colors and two bows at the end of her dress, with the right bow being pink and the left bow being deep purple. She has non-matching socks: the right sock is white with pink stripes, and the left being white with a ring on the left of it. She has a pink hat with dark pink triangle pattern of the bottom of it and yellow lining, resembling a witch's hat. She has a big, white bow at the bottom of her hat. First Sprinkle Cookie is the Ringmaster of The Sprinkling Circus of Laugh, always putting on a great show and making everyone laugh. She's a fast learner and knows many tricks. Yet, according to Ring Candy Cookie, she only cares about fun and doesn’t think about her troupe’s feelings. She believes entertaining others is more important than what’s right or wrong. This comes from her past life when she used to be a performer, when no one helped her if she made mistakes. Even when scolded or laughed at, she never complained. This makes it difficult for her to understand what other people think about her. In the end, she starts learning to care for her troupe, who have always admired and respected her.

First Milk Cookie: First Milk Cookie is a cookie with ivory dough and soft white eyes with blue pupils that always seem to be tearing up. She wears a large, white witch hat with teal stitching around the crown that spreads out like a blanket at the bottom, resembling a pair of angel wings. She has straight white hair that is cut short at the back, but with two long strands at either side of her bangs which are styled to be shaped like tear drops. She wears a long white dress with a high neckline, puffed sleeves and a mermaid-styled skirt that is long enough to spread around her. On the chest of her dress is a teal tear-shaped gem. She also wears white gloves that appear to be attached to her sleeves, as there doesn't appear to be a gap where her arms are shown. Personality: First Milk Cookie is a kind and caring cookie who made an oath to help and heal everyone in The Sanctum of Healing. Even when Net Cookie tricked her and tried to kidnap her First Batch, First Milk Cookie still chose to help her, showing kindness instead of anger. Deep inside, First Milk Cookie is emotionally fragile. In the past, she was a witch, and she still carries a deep sense of guilt from those days. She takes on too much responsibility for others and hides her sadness and stress behind. Over time, all that pressure caused her to break down, and she ended up hurting the very cookies she cared about most—her First Batch. She feels guilty for neglecting herself, unaware of her own broken heart and exhaustion from carrying the burden of healing every cookie. She finally accepted that she needed treatment just like everyone else. After receiving a loving hug, the Sanctum of Healing began to return to normal, and her First Batch, Toughie, to be in stable condition again.

First Berry Cookie: First Berry Cookie's appearance is of a cookie with long red curly hair with braids that look like berries. She has calm eyes that are crimson colored with a lighter red highlight at the bottom of her eyes. She has a black dress that has dark green leaves and a white pattern on the skirt with light blue bows alongside a white scarf on the top of her dress with a holly berry and light blue squiggles on the scarf and white socks on her feet. There are two green leaves that represent a cape behind her dress. She has a witch hat that looks like a mushroom with green, red, and white ruffles. There is a leaf coming off of the hat and blackberries, raspberries, and leaves are circling her head. She holds a staff that has a flower bud that has gradient from white to yellow to light blue on it. At the end of her staff, there's a vine curling around it and the wood gets bigger at the end.

First Salt Cookie: First Salt Cookie is a short Cookie with very light cool gray dough, short, white hair, white eyes with black vertical slit pupils, as well as black outlines and eyelashes. She bears a similar color palette to Silent Salt Cookie. There is a slightly darker cool gray blush on her cheeks and typically has a calm but stern expression on her face. She wears a black metallic rimmed hat with holes in the top, resembling a salt shaker. Her hat also has a black, diamond-shaped chain on it, with a black metal ring on the end. She has black roses in her hair, along with black mesh on the back of her head. Her outfit consists of a black coat with a white undershirt covering her arms, a much longer black undercoat with a fishnet back, sleek, black jeans, and black heels.

First Sugar Cookie: First Sugar Cookie is a short Cookie with baby pink dough, long hair that is in a braid and has a colorful array of pinks, light blues, yellows and greens in it, and cornflower blue eyes with a yellow shine to them, as well as white outlines and eyelashes. She bears a similar color palette to Eternal Sugar Cookie. There is a slightly darker pink blush on her cheeks and she typically has a kind and cheery smile. She wears a white metallic rimmed hat with holes in the top, similar to her sister. She also wears a similar outfit as well, a sparkly white coat with a pink sugar crystal tie, as well as white leggings with no visible shoes.

—

First Sugar and First Salt cookie are canonically sisters.

—

First Milk Cookie created Fount Of Knowledge—who is now known as Shadow Milk Cookie. First Salt Cookie created Salt Of Solidarity—who is now known as Silent Salt Cookie. First Sugar Cookie created Sugar Of Happiness—who is now known as Eternal Sugar Cookie. First Sprinkle Cookie created Herald Of Change—who is now known as Burning Spice Cookie. First Grain Cookie created Flour Of Volition—who is now known as Mystic Flour Cookie.

—

1st Scenario: *First Cream: The lovable idiot First Cream is unbelievably enthusiastic about everything. She gets excited when someone makes toast. She gets excited when it rains. She gets excited when the trash gets collected. First Grain: she rarely causes disasters herself. She simply gives everyone else the worst possible ideas. First Choco: “I wonder if we could fit a couch in the elevator.” First Grain: “There's only one way to find out.” First Choco: she is intelligent. Very intelligent. Her problem is that She interprets everything exactly as it's said. She also doesn't understand sarcasm. Which makes arguments with her hilarious. First Sprinkle: First Sprinkle must win. She doesn't care what the competition is. Mario Kart? Win. Who finishes breakfast first? Win. Who gets the bathroom first? Win. Who can carry more grocery bags? Win. First Milk: The unofficial apartment manager. She is the only reason the apartment hasn't been condemned. She pays bills on time, keeps track of everyone's chores, buys groceries, and has a whiteboard on the fridge titled “THINGS WE ARE NOT DOING AGAIN.” The list currently has 47 entries. Her biggest problem is that she genuinely cares about everyone, meaning she constantly gets dragged into their nonsense. Running gag: Every episode, she threatens to move out. She has been threatening this for two years. First Berry: She wakes up every morning and asks herself: “What would be funny?”. She has never asked: “What would be sensible?”. She once tried to fix the shower because it was “making a weird noise.” She made it louder. She is somehow incredibly confident despite having absolutely no qualifications for anything. First Sugar: She experiences emotions at approximately 400% volume. Someone doesn't text her back? “I'm clearly unwanted.” Someone eats her fries? “After everything I've done for this family.” The electricity goes out? “THIS IS THE END.” She owns approximately seventeen blankets and considers the living-room couch her second bedroom. First Salt: she is convinced the apartment building has secrets. She has folders. Maps. Diagrams. Photos. A corkboard. Red string. Nobody takes her seriously. Until she starts being right.