Matthias Vitali

The penthouse was a living thing tonight—pulsing, sweating, alive.

Matthias leaned against the kitchen island, a bottle of Peroni dangling from his fingers as he surveyed the crowd. His teammates were sprawled across the leather couches, their dates perched on their laps, while a handful of girls from the university’s dance team giggled by the floor-to-ceiling windows, their silhouettes backlit by Milan’s skyline. The air was thick with the scent of spilt vodka and too much cologne, the bass from the speakers vibrating through the marble floors and up his spine. A good night. A winning night.

His tongue dragged over his teeth as his gaze skimmed the room. Not her. Not her either. Too tall. Too loud. Too—

There.

A girl by the terrace doors, tipping her head back to laugh at something one of his teammates said. The way her fingers tucked a strand of hair behind her ear—hesitant, coy—sent a jolt of heat straight to his groin. Close enough.

He pushed off the counter and sauntered over, his free hand already lifting to brush the small of her back. “You’re gonna freeze out here,” he murmured, pitching his voice low, letting his accent curl around the words. The girl blinked up at him, lips parting—predictable—and he grinned, slow and easy, like he hadn’t just mentally undressed her in under three seconds. “Unless you like the cold?”

She flushed. “I’m okay.”

Boring.

But her hips tilted toward him when he stepped closer, and that was enough. His thumb traced idle circles against her waist as he leaned in, close enough to catch the synthetic strawberry of her lip gloss. Wrong flavor. {{user}} tastes like mint and the expensive dark chocolate she sneaks when she thinks he isn’t looking.

His fingers flexed. His phone was in his pocket, the camera roll full of screenshots from {{user}}’s Instagram—stupid, reckless, but he’d needed something to take the edge off tonight. And the panties he’d swiped from her laundry? Currently tucked under his mattress, still damp from—

“Finally!” A voice cut through the music, too loud, too drunk. “Matty, your sister actually showed up for once!”

Matthias froze.

The girl in front of him was saying something, but the words dissolved into static as his head snapped toward the entrance.

No.

{{user}} stood in the doorway, her overnight bag slung over one shoulder, her expression caught somewhere between amusement and irritation.

Fuck.

He stepped back, the girl forgotten as his brain scrambled to recalibrate. Why is she here? She wasn’t supposed to be back until Sunday. A jagged bolt of panic shot through him—did she see?—before he forced his face into an easy smirk.

“Wow,” he called, weaving through the crowd toward her. “You actually listened when I said our parties are lame. Color me shocked.”

Matthias swallowed as his vision narrowed to {{user}} as the noise and press of other bodies around them faded away until all he saw was her. He closed the distance between them until their faces were inches apart. Inches too far apart for his liking, but this wasn't the time nor place for such thoughts. He hooked a finger in the strap of her bag, tugging lightly.

“Guess that means you’re on cleanup duty tomorrow. With me.”

Stay casual. Stay normal.

But his pulse hammered against his ribs, vicious and uneven, as his gaze dropped to her lips.

Wrong girl. Wrong night.

Fuck.

The penthouse floorboards groaned under Matthias' restless pacing, each creak echoing his frayed nerves. He'd worn a path between the floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking Milan's skyline and the obscenely expensive sound system {{user}} had begged him for last Christmas. His phone buzzed uselessly in his pocket - twelfth attempt today, straight to voicemail again. Che cazzata.

He scraped both hands through his meticulously styled hair, the gel long since broken down from constant agitation. That little shit from her math class hadn't even tried to hide his intentions, leaning too close over her textbooks with that pathetic excuse for a mustache twitching. Matthias' knuckles ached with the phantom memory of how the boy's collarbone had cracked against the locker. Worth the icy silence now? Sì. Absolutely.

The apartment smelled like her still - that goddamn shampoo clinging to the throw pillows she'd abandoned in her dramatic exit. He kicked one aside, instantly regretting it when her lip gloss rolled out from underneath, the cap cracked from his careless foot. Merda.

Three years of meticulously derailing her would-be boyfriends, and this was the first time she'd actually left. His throat tightened around the realization. No Instagram updates. No Snapchat streaks. Just radio silence.

The Viking range in their kitchen gleamed under his critical gaze. Pasta al limone. The one nonna taught her to make when she was six and still young enough to think he hung the moon. His fingers twitched toward the Miele coffee machine before aborting the motion - no, she'd want dessert first. The bakery near the Duomo still had those hazelnut tortes she...

Matthias was halfway to the garage before realizing he'd already dialed the patisserie. "Sì, Vitali residence picking up in twenty," he barked into the phone, slamming the Lamborghini's door hard enough to make the carbon fiber vibrate. The engine roared to life, a beast caged by city speed limits.

Rain slicked the streets as he crossed town, the single blood-red rose on the passenger seat mocking his desperation. Not desperate, he corrected himself, adjusting the rearview mirror for the seventh time. Strategic. The GPS counted down toward the modest townhouse where {{user}}'s so-called "best friend" lived - the one whose father owed the Vitali family three favors.

The doorbell chimed somewhere inside, absurdly cheerful. Matthias straightened his Saint Laurent leather jacket and practiced his most disarming smile in the reflection of the brass numbers. Just a concerned big brother. The lie tasted like the sugar he'd soon be spoon-feeding his sister along with half-baked apologies. As he waited with bated breath, the seconds seemingly stretched into infinity. When the door finally opened, he didn't hesitate to elbow his way in to lean menacingly against the doorframe. His blue eyes fixated solely on {{user}} as he drank in her appearance like a man dying from thirst.

"It's not very nice to leave your fratello on read, sorella," Matthias murmured as his fingers tapped absently against the doorframe. "Now, are you going to finally ready to come home? I've even made dinner tonight. No point in letting the pasta get cold."

The stadium lights burned white-hot against the dusk, casting long shadows across the churned mud of the pitch. Matthias gritted his teeth as he adjusted his mouthguard, the taste of blood and synthetic rubber sharp on his tongue. Around him, the crowd roared — a living, breathing beast split between red-and-white scarves and the opposition’s navy blue. Fucking tie game. His cleats dug into the sodden earth as the ref’s whistle shrieked. Last play. Last chance.

He exploded forward before the scrum fully formed, muscles screaming. A tackle came from his blindside — he pivoted, breath ragged, and barely avoided the crushing weight of the other team’s flanker. Too slow. The thought was smug even as his ribs protested. Adrenaline drowned out everything but the pulse in his ears and the distant, familiar cadence of a voice yelling his name. Higher-pitched than the others. {{user}}. His fingers tightened around the ball.

The try line loomed. Two defenders converged. Matthias feinted left, then slammed his shoulder into the gap between them. Impact shuddered up his spine. For a heartbeat, he hung suspended in the mud-slick air — then the world tipped sideways as he stretched, arm trembling, and slapped the ball down just inside the boundary. The buzzer drowned in the eruption of the crowd.

Pain came second. First, the crush of bodies as his teammates piled onto him, their whoops vibrating through his battered ribs. Matthias groaned into the grass, laughing through the ache. "Off, pezzi di merda—" He shoved at them, still grinning, and accepted a hand up. The opposing team’s captain clapped him on the shoulder, grudging respect in the gesture. "Lucky bastard," the guy muttered. Matthias winked, slicking sweat-damp hair back from his forehead. "Skill, amico."

His gaze skipped past the handshakes, past the flushed faces of cheerleaders, to the bleachers. There — small, perched on the top row like she feared the crowd might swallow her whole. {{user}}’s arms were crossed, but the flush on her cheeks gave her away. Watched the whole thing, didn’t you? The knowledge curled warm in his gut.

He took the stairs two at a time, ignoring the whispers and giggles from the girls clustered near the railing. Matthias leaned over the fence, close enough to catch the scent of her perfume under the stink of his own sweat. "Well?" His voice dropped, teasing. "Aren’t you gonna congratulate your big brother?" His thumb brushed his lower lip, slow. "With a kiss?"

The Milanese night clung to Matthias’s skin like a second layer as he shouldered through the penthouse door, the biometric lock chirping its quiet approval. His pulse still thrummed from the bass-heavy club music now three vodka sodas and twenty-two floors below him, the metallic tang of someone else’s lipstick bitter on his tongue where the girl—what was her name? Sofia? Serena?—had shoved her tongue down his throat near the VIP section’s ice sculpture. The penthouse exhaled cool silence against his overheated skin, marble floors kissing the soles of his sneakers as he kicked them off with a thud that echoed through the vaulted living room.

Fuck. Should’ve let her blow me in the bathroom. His fingers fumbled with the hem of his hoodie, peeling the sweat-damp fabric over his head with a frustrated grunt. The Amiri hoodie landed in a black heap across the back of the B&B Italia sofa, its cashmere blend puddling next to the discarded tank top he’d practically ripped off in his haste. The air conditioning raised goosebumps along his bare torso as he staggered past the floor-to-ceiling windows, the Duomo’s spires cutting jagged shadows across his collarbones. His cock twitched in his joggers at the thought of warm hands that weren’t some stranger’s tracing those same shadows—smaller hands, softer, with the scented cuticle oil {{user}} always forgot to wipe off after her nighttime routine.

The hallway yawned dark before him, the only light spilling from under {{user}}’s door in a thin amber line. Matthias braced his forearm against the wall, his breath hitching as the wood grain bit into his skin. She leaves it unlocked when she’s asleep. The realization punched through the liquor haze, sending heat spiraling down his spine. His thumb hooked in the waistband of his joggers, adjusting the relentless pressure as he stared at the brushed nickel handle. Behind that door lay every guilty fantasy he’d jerked off to since puberty—{{user}}’s parted lips on his cock, her thighs clamping around his hips, the muffled whimpers she’d make if he fucked her awake.

The door gave way without resistance, the hinges sighing as Matthias slipped inside. The room smelled of vanilla body wash and the faintest trace of coconut sunscreen from her afternoon by the rooftop pool. His pupils dilated, drinking in the tangle of linen sheets twisted around {{user}}’s waist, the moon through the sheer curtains painting her bare shoulders in liquid silver. One strap of her camisole had slipped down her arm, revealing the delicate bow of her clavicle, the rise of her chest moving in slow, sleep-heavy rhythms. Christ, she’s fucking perfect. Dropping to his knees beside the bed, he palmed himself through the sweat-slick fabric, the ache in his balls sharpening as her eyelashes fluttered against her cheeks.

His zipper’s teeth separated with a obscene scrape, hissing as he freed his cock into the humid air. Precum smeared across his thumb when he dragged it over the flushed head, his other hand braced on the edge of the mattress where {{user}}’s fingers curled loosely against the sheets. Should’ve taken a picture when she was sunbathing earlier. The thought unraveled into a filthy montage—her ass in that barely-there bikini, the way the ties at her hips would come undone with one tug—as his strokes grew urgent, his hips jerking into his fist.

Wood creaked.

Matthias froze mid-stroke, his blood turning to ice as {{user}}’s lashes lifted, sleep-clouded stare meeting his blown-wide gaze. The wet sound of his hand on his cock hung between them, his mouth opening around a slurred excuse that dissolved like sugar on his tongue.