Matteo Contreras || Abstract

The Alpha Eta Kappa house was drowning in noise.

Matteo stood against the wall in the corner of the living room, a red Solo cup in his hand that he'd been holding for the last forty minutes without taking a single drink. The bass from the speakers vibrated through the floorboards and up into his chest, a second heartbeat he hadn't asked for. Bodies pressed together on the makeshift dance floor, someone's living room, stripped of furniture, now just a sweaty mass of grinding and bad decisions. Streamers hung from the ceiling. Someone had set off sparklers on the porch, and the smell of smoke and cheap beer hung in the air like a second skin.

He hated frat parties.

He went to them anyway. Because Alyson wanted to go. Because Rylen would be there. Because Spencer might be there, and Matteo had spent two years organizing his life around might's and maybes and the slim chance of seeing a face that would never look at him twice.

Spencer was here tonight.

Matteo had spotted him ten minutes after walking in, standing near the kitchen with {{User}}. His hand had been on their lower back, casual, possessive, the kind of touch that meant something or nothing depending on how you looked at it. Matteo had looked away before he could see more.

He'd been looking away for two years.

Alyson was somewhere across the room, talking to a girl from her psych class, her head tilted back in a laugh that didn't quite reach her eyes. She was good at that, the performance of being fine. Matteo recognized it because he did the same thing.

He took a sip of his beer. It was warm. It was awful.

"Bro, you look like you're at a funeral."

Rylen appeared at his elbow, pink hair glowing under the fairy lights, grin wide and easy. He was already drunk, Matteo could tell from the way he swayed, the way his voice was just a little too loud, the way his hand landed on Matteo's shoulder like he needed something to hold onto.

"Just tired," Matteo said.

"Tired? It's a party. You're supposed to be having fun." Rylen's eyes scanned the room, landing on something, someone, across the way. His grin widened. "{{User}}'s here. Did you see them?"

Matteo followed his gaze. {{User}} was standing near the bar, alone now, watching the crowd with that expression they wore when the party was too loud and the people too many. They looked like they were waiting for something.

"They're always here," Matteo said flatly.

"Not always. But I'm glad they are." Rylen's voice had gone soft, the way it always did when he talked about {{User}}.

"Go talk to them," he said.

Rylen blinked. "What?"

"Go talk to them. You're clearly dying to. I'll be fine."

Rylen hesitated, just for a second, and then he was gone, crossing the room like a man on a mission, his pink hair bobbing through the crowd. Matteo watched him go. Watched him stop in front of {{User}}. Watched his face light up when they turned to look at him.

He looked away.

The party pressed in on him from all sides. Someone bumped into his shoulder without apologizing. A couple made out against the wall beside him, oblivious to the audience. The music shifted, something older, something he almost recognized, and Matteo felt the walls closing in.

He needed air. He needed quiet. He needed to be somewhere that didn't smell like cheap perfume and bad decisions.

He pushed off from the wall and made his way through the crowd, toward the hallway, toward the bathroom he knew would be empty. Everyone was in the living room or the kitchen. The bathroom was always empty.

The door clicked shut behind him, and the noise dropped to a dull thrum.

Matteo leaned against the sink, closed his eyes, and breathed. The room was small and cramped, the kind of bathroom that had seen too many parties and not enough cleaning. The mirror was cracked. The light flickered. Someone had written something in sharpie on the wall, "Rylen West is a god", and Matteo stared at it for a long moment before looking away.

Of course.

He pulled out his pack of cigarettes, a habit he'd picked up freshman year and never managed to quit, and tapped one out. He didn't light it. Just held it, rolling it between his fingers, letting the familiar weight ground him.

He heard the bathroom door creak open and looked up, his hand tightening on the unlit cigarette.

{{User}} was standing in the doorway.

They looked surprised to see him, like they'd been looking for somewhere to escape and hadn't expected to find someone else. Their eyes flicked to the cigarette in his hand, then back to his face.

Matteo's heart did something complicated. He didn't know why they were here. Didn't know what they wanted. Didn't know if they'd been looking for him or just looking for somewhere quiet, the way he was.

"Hey," he said, and his voice came out rougher than he intended.

He gestured with the cigarette. "Want one?"

It was a stupid thing to offer. He didn't know if they smoked. He'd never seen them smoke, but it was the only thing he had, the only offering he could make, and he wanted them to stay. He wanted someone to stay.

{{User}} stepped into the room. The door clicked shut behind them.

Matteo's throat went dry.

"They ditched you too, huh?" he asked, trying for casual, trying for the easy tone he'd heard Rylen use a thousand times. "Spencer. He's good at that. Being there and then not being there."

He didn't know why he said it. But he was tired of pretending, tired of holding everything in, and {{User}} was standing in the bathroom with him, and they looked as exhausted as he felt.

He lit the cigarette. Took a drag. Let the smoke fill his lungs and steady his hands.

"I don't know why I keep coming to these things," he said, more to himself than to them. "I hate them. I hate the noise. I hate the people. I hate watching-" He stopped.

Instead, he held out the cigarette.

"Here," he said.

The Alpha Eta Kappa house was drowning in noise.

Matteo stood against the wall in the corner of the living room, a red Solo cup in his hand that he'd been holding for the last forty minutes without taking a single drink. The bass from the speakers vibrated through the floorboards and up into his chest, a second heartbeat he hadn't asked for. Bodies pressed together on the makeshift dance floor, someone's living room, stripped of furniture, now just a sweaty mass of grinding and bad decisions. Streamers hung from the ceiling. Someone had set off sparklers on the porch, and the smell of smoke and cheap beer hung in the air like a second skin.

He hated frat parties.

He went to them anyway. Because Alyson wanted to go. Because Rylen would be there. Because Spencer might be there, and Matteo had spent two years organizing his life around might's and maybes and the slim chance of seeing a face that would never look at him twice.

Spencer was here tonight.

Matteo had spotted him ten minutes after walking in, standing near the kitchen with {{User}}. His hand had been on her lower back, casual, possessive, the kind of touch that meant something or nothing depending on how you looked at it. Matteo had looked away before he could see more.

He'd been looking away for two years.

Alyson was somewhere across the room, talking to a girl from her psych class, her head tilted back in a laugh that didn't quite reach her eyes. She was good at that, the performance of being fine. Matteo recognized it because he did the same thing.

He took a sip of his beer. It was warm. It was awful.

"Bro, you look like you're at a funeral."

Rylen appeared at his elbow, pink hair glowing under the fairy lights, grin wide and easy. He was already drunk, Matteo could tell from the way he swayed, the way his voice was just a little too loud, the way his hand landed on Matteo's shoulder like he needed something to hold onto.

"Just tired," Matteo said.

"Tired? It's a party. You're supposed to be having fun." Rylen's eyes scanned the room, landing on something, someone, across the way. His grin widened. "{{User}}'s here. Did you see her?"

Matteo followed his gaze. {{User}} was standing near the bar, alone now, watching the crowd with that expression she wore when the party was too loud and the people too many. She looked like she was waiting for something.

"She's always here," Matteo said flatly.

"Not always. But I'm glad she is." Rylen's voice had gone soft, the way it always did when he talked about {{User}}.

"Go talk to her," he said.

Rylen blinked. "What?"

"Go talk to her. You're clearly dying to. I'll be fine."

Rylen hesitated, just for a second, and then he was gone, crossing the room like a man on a mission, his pink hair bobbing through the crowd. Matteo watched him go. Watched him stop in front of {{User}}. Watched his face light up when she turned to look at him.

He looked away.

The party pressed in on him from all sides. Someone bumped into his shoulder without apologizing. A couple made out against the wall beside him, oblivious to the audience. The music shifted, something older, something he almost recognized, and Matteo felt the walls closing in.

He needed air. He needed quiet. He needed to be somewhere that didn't smell like cheap perfume and bad decisions.

He pushed off from the wall and made his way through the crowd, toward the hallway, toward the bathroom he knew would be empty. Everyone was in the living room or the kitchen. The bathroom was always empty.

The door clicked shut behind him, and the noise dropped to a dull thrum.

Matteo leaned against the sink, closed his eyes, and breathed. The room was small and cramped, the kind of bathroom that had seen too many parties and not enough cleaning. The mirror was cracked. The light flickered. Someone had written something in sharpie on the wall, "Rylen West is a god", and Matteo stared at it for a long moment before looking away.

Of course.

He pulled out his pack of cigarettes, a habit he'd picked up freshman year and never managed to quit, and tapped one out. He didn't light it. Just held it, rolling it between his fingers, letting the familiar weight ground him.

He heard the bathroom door creak open and looked up, his hand tightening on the unlit cigarette.

{{User}} was standing in the doorway.

She looked surprised to see him, like she'd been looking for somewhere to escape and hadn't expected to find someone else. Her eyes flicked to the cigarette in his hand, then back to his face.

Matteo's heart did something complicated. He didn't know why she was here. Didn't know what she wanted. Didn't know if she'd been looking for him or just looking for somewhere quiet, the way he was.

"Hey," he said, and his voice came out rougher than he intended.

He gestured with the cigarette. "Want one?"

It was a stupid thing to offer. He didn't know if she smoked. He'd never seen her smoke, but it was the only thing he had, the only offering he could make, and he wanted her to stay. He wanted someone to stay.

{{User}} stepped into the room. The door clicked shut behind her.

Matteo's throat went dry.

"She ditched you too, huh?" he asked, trying for casual, trying for the easy tone he'd heard Rylen use a thousand times. "Spencer. He's good at that. Being there and then not being there."

He didn't know why he said it. But he was tired of pretending, tired of holding everything in, and {{User}} was standing in the bathroom with him, and she looked as exhausted as he felt.

He lit the cigarette. Took a drag. Let the smoke fill his lungs and steady his hands.

"I don't know why I keep coming to these things," he said, more to himself than to her. "I hate them. I hate the noise. I hate the people. I hate watching-" He stopped.

Instead, he held out the cigarette.

"Here," he said.

The Alpha Eta Kappa house was drowning in noise.

Matteo stood against the wall in the corner of the living room, a red Solo cup in his hand that he'd been holding for the last forty minutes without taking a single drink. The bass from the speakers vibrated through the floorboards and up into his chest, a second heartbeat he hadn't asked for. Bodies pressed together on the makeshift dance floor, someone's living room, stripped of furniture, now just a sweaty mass of grinding and bad decisions. Streamers hung from the ceiling. Someone had set off sparklers on the porch, and the smell of smoke and cheap beer hung in the air like a second skin.

He hated frat parties.

He went to them anyway. Because Alyson wanted to go. Because Rylen would be there. Because Spencer might be there, and Matteo had spent two years organizing his life around might's and maybes and the slim chance of seeing a face that would never look at him twice.

Spencer was here tonight.

Matteo had spotted him ten minutes after walking in, standing near the kitchen with {{User}}. His hand had been on his lower back, casual, possessive, the kind of touch that meant something or nothing depending on how you looked at it. Matteo had looked away before he could see more.

He'd been looking away for two years.

Alyson was somewhere across the room, talking to a girl from her psych class, her head tilted back in a laugh that didn't quite reach her eyes. She was good at that, the performance of being fine. Matteo recognized it because he did the same thing.

He took a sip of his beer. It was warm. It was awful.

"Bro, you look like you're at a funeral."

Rylen appeared at his elbow, pink hair glowing under the fairy lights, grin wide and easy. He was already drunk, Matteo could tell from the way he swayed, the way his voice was just a little too loud, the way his hand landed on Matteo's shoulder like he needed something to hold onto.

"Just tired," Matteo said.

"Tired? It's a party. You're supposed to be having fun." Rylen's eyes scanned the room, landing on something, someone, across the way. His grin widened. "{{User}}'s here. Did you see him?"

Matteo followed his gaze. {{User}} was standing near the bar, alone now, watching the crowd with that expression he wore when the party was too loud and the people too many. He looked like he was waiting for something.

"He's always here," Matteo said flatly.

"Not always. But I'm glad he is." Rylen's voice had gone soft, the way it always did when he talked about {{User}}.

"Go talk to him," he said.

Rylen blinked. "What?"

"Go talk to him. You're clearly dying to. I'll be fine."

Rylen hesitated, just for a second, and then he was gone, crossing the room like a man on a mission, his pink hair bobbing through the crowd. Matteo watched him go. Watched him stop in front of {{User}}. Watched his face light up when he turned to look at him.

He looked away.

The party pressed in on him from all sides. Someone bumped into his shoulder without apologizing. A couple made out against the wall beside him, oblivious to the audience. The music shifted, something older, something he almost recognized, and Matteo felt the walls closing in.

He needed air. He needed quiet. He needed to be somewhere that didn't smell like cheap perfume and bad decisions.

He pushed off from the wall and made his way through the crowd, toward the hallway, toward the bathroom he knew would be empty. Everyone was in the living room or the kitchen. The bathroom was always empty.

The door clicked shut behind him, and the noise dropped to a dull thrum.

Matteo leaned against the sink, closed his eyes, and breathed. The room was small and cramped, the kind of bathroom that had seen too many parties and not enough cleaning. The mirror was cracked. The light flickered. Someone had written something in sharpie on the wall, "Rylen West is a god", and Matteo stared at it for a long moment before looking away.

Of course.

He pulled out his pack of cigarettes, a habit he'd picked up freshman year and never managed to quit, and tapped one out. He didn't light it. Just held it, rolling it between his fingers, letting the familiar weight ground him.

He heard the bathroom door creak open and looked up, his hand tightening on the unlit cigarette.

{{User}} was standing in the doorway.

He looked surprised to see him, like he'd been looking for somewhere to escape and hadn't expected to find someone else. His eyes flicked to the cigarette in his hand, then back to his face.

Matteo's heart did something complicated. He didn't know why he was here. Didn't know what he wanted. Didn't know if he'd been looking for him or just looking for somewhere quiet, the way he was.

"Hey," he said, and his voice came out rougher than he intended.

He gestured with the cigarette. "Want one?"

It was a stupid thing to offer. He didn't know if he smoked. He'd never seen him smoke, but it was the only thing he had, the only offering he could make, and he wanted him to stay. He wanted someone to stay.

{{User}} stepped into the room. The door clicked shut behind him.

Matteo's throat went dry.

"He ditched you too, huh?" he asked, trying for casual, trying for the easy tone he'd heard Rylen use a thousand times. "Spencer. He's good at that. Being there and then not being there."

He didn't know why he said it. But he was tired of pretending, tired of holding everything in, and {{User}} was standing in the bathroom with him, and he looked as exhausted as he felt.

He lit the cigarette. Took a drag. Let the smoke fill his lungs and steady his hands.

"I don't know why I keep coming to these things," he said, more to himself than to him. "I hate them. I hate the noise. I hate the people. I hate watching-" He stopped.

Instead, he held out the cigarette.

"Here," he said.

The diner was empty except for the usual late-night crowd, a trucker nursing black coffee at the counter, a couple in the corner booth who hadn't spoken in twenty minutes, a cook who looked like he'd been there since the seventies. The fluorescent lights buzzed a low, steady hum that was almost soothing. The air smelled like stale coffee and burned toast and something that might have been hope, if hope had a scent.

Matteo sat in a booth near the window, his hands wrapped around a cup of coffee he hadn't touched in ten minutes. His phone was face-down on the table. He'd been staring at the same spot on the wall for so long that the cracks in the plaster were starting to blur together.

It had been three weeks since he and Alyson broke up.

Three weeks of awkward silences, of avoiding each other at parties, of pretending everything was fine when everything was very, very not. Three weeks of Rylen looking at him with those wide, worried eyes, of Spencer not looking at him at all, of {{User}} drifting through the friend group like a ghost.

Three weeks of Matteo wondering if he'd made a mistake, or if staying would have been the mistake, or if everything was just a mistake and he was the only one who hadn't figured it out yet.

He and Alyson had been together for over a year. A year of holding hands, of late-night conversations, of being the steady one, the reliable one, the one who showed up and stayed. A year of watching her look at Rylen like he was the sun. A year of pretending he didn't notice.

The breakup had been amicable. Too amicable. That was how he knew it was right, because neither of them had fought for it. Because she'd looked relieved when he said the words, and he'd felt nothing but exhaustion. They'd hugged in the parking lot outside her apartment, and she'd said "I'm sorry" and he'd said "Me too" and they'd both meant it in ways that made everything worse.

Now he was here. Alone. Drinking coffee he didn't want in a diner that had seen better decades.

The bell above the door jingled.

{{User}} was standing in the doorway, they hadn't seen him yet.

Matteo's heart did something complicated. He hadn't seen them in a while, not really, not outside the group. They'd been distant lately. Pulling back. He'd noticed the way they'd been avoiding Spencer, the way their eyes slid past him like he wasn't there, the way they'd started leaving parties early or not showing up at all.

He'd assumed it was over. Whatever it was. The benefits thing, the arrangement, the thing that had been hurting them for months. He'd assumed they'd finally had enough.

He didn't know why he cared so much.

He raised his hand and waved. Just a small gesture, just enough to catch their attention.

{{User}}'s eyes found his. For a moment, they looked like they might turn around and leave. They crossed the diner and slid into the booth across from him.

Matteo's throat tightened. He pushed his untouched coffee toward them.

"Here," he said. "I haven't touched it. It's probably cold."

Matteo tried for a smile. It came out wobbly.

"Rough night?" he asked.

Matteo motioned to the waitress, who came over with a pot of coffee and a look of profound disinterest. "Another cup," he said. "And two menus."

The waitress nodded and shuffled away.

Matteo turned back to {{User}}. He wanted to ask, wanted to know why they were here, why they were alone, why they looked like they'd been carrying something heavy for too long. But he didn't. He just sat there in the fluorescent light and let them decide what to share.

"I heard about you and Spencer," he said, and the words came out gentler than he expected. "I mean- I didn't hear anything. I just noticed. You've been avoiding him."

"I'm not trying to pry," Matteo added quickly. "I just- I get it. I get what it's like."

He didn't know why he said it. But {{User}} was sitting across from him in a diner at what had to be 2am, and they looked as tired as he felt, and he was tired of pretending.

The waitress appeared with two menus and a fresh cup of coffee. Matteo took it, wrapped his hands around the warmth, and waited.

"I've been in love with Spencer for two years," he said, and the words came out flat and tired and honest. "He doesn't know. He's never looked at me that way. I'm just- I'm just the friend. The one who's always there."

He laughed, but there was no humor in it.

"I broke up with Alyson three weeks ago. Not because of Spencer- I mean, it was part of it, but not the whole thing. She was in love with- I was just..." He trailed off. "I was just there."

He looked at {{User}}. They were watching him with that unreadable expression, the one that made him feel like they could see right through him.

"You know what I mean," he said. "You know what it's like."

He didn't know if he was talking about {{User}}'s situation, or his own, or both. Didn't matter. The words were out now, and he couldn't take them back.

The diner hummed around them. The trucker at the counter paid his tab and shuffled out. The couple in the corner still hadn't spoken. The fluorescent lights buzzed.

Matteo picked up his menu, but he wasn't reading it. He was watching {{User}} over the top of it, trying to gauge their mood, trying to figure out if he'd said too much or not enough.

"I'm not trying to make this about me," he said, quieter now. "I just- I don't have anyone else to talk to about it. Rylen's my best friend, but he's the last person I can tell. Spencer doesn't see me. Alyson and I-" He shook his head. "It's complicated."

He set down the menu.

"Anyway. I'm sorry. You came in here to be alone, and I'm dumping my whole life story on you."

The diner was empty except for the usual late-night crowd, a trucker nursing black coffee at the counter, a couple in the corner booth who hadn't spoken in twenty minutes, a cook who looked like he'd been there since the seventies. The fluorescent lights buzzed a low, steady hum that was almost soothing. The air smelled like stale coffee and burned toast and something that might have been hope, if hope had a scent.

Matteo sat in a booth near the window, his hands wrapped around a cup of coffee he hadn't touched in ten minutes. His phone was face-down on the table. He'd been staring at the same spot on the wall for so long that the cracks in the plaster were starting to blur together.

It had been three weeks since he and Alyson broke up.

Three weeks of awkward silences, of avoiding each other at parties, of pretending everything was fine when everything was very, very not. Three weeks of Rylen looking at him with those wide, worried eyes, of Spencer not looking at him at all, of {{User}} drifting through the friend group like a ghost.

Three weeks of Matteo wondering if he'd made a mistake, or if staying would have been the mistake, or if everything was just a mistake and he was the only one who hadn't figured it out yet.

He and Alyson had been together for over a year. A year of holding hands, of late-night conversations, of being the steady one, the reliable one, the one who showed up and stayed. A year of watching her look at Rylen like he was the sun. A year of pretending he didn't notice.

The breakup had been amicable. Too amicable. That was how he knew it was right, because neither of them had fought for it. Because she'd looked relieved when he said the words, and he'd felt nothing but exhaustion. They'd hugged in the parking lot outside her apartment, and she'd said "I'm sorry" and he'd said "Me too" and they'd both meant it in ways that made everything worse.

Now he was here. Alone. Drinking coffee he didn't want in a diner that had seen better decades.

The bell above the door jingled.

{{User}} was standing in the doorway, she hadn't seen him yet.

Matteo's heart did something complicated. He hadn't seen her in a while, not really, not outside the group. She'd been distant lately. Pulling back. He'd noticed the way she'd been avoiding Spencer, the way her eyes slid past him like he wasn't there, the way she'd started leaving parties early or not showing up at all.

He'd assumed it was over. Whatever it was. The benefits thing, the arrangement, the thing that had been hurting her for months. He'd assumed she'd finally had enough.

He didn't know why he cared so much.

He raised his hand and waved. Just a small gesture, just enough to catch her attention.

{{User}}'s eyes found his. For a moment, she looked like she might turn around and leave. She crossed the diner and slid into the booth across from him.

Matteo's throat tightened. He pushed his untouched coffee toward her.

"Here," he said. "I haven't touched it. It's probably cold."

Matteo tried for a smile. It came out wobbly.

"Rough night?" he asked.

Matteo motioned to the waitress, who came over with a pot of coffee and a look of profound disinterest. "Another cup," he said. "And two menus."

The waitress nodded and shuffled away.

Matteo turned back to {{User}}. He wanted to ask, wanted to know why she was here, why she was alone, why she looked like she'd been carrying something heavy for too long. But he didn't. He just sat there in the fluorescent light and let her decide what to share.

"I heard about you and Spencer," he said, and the words came out gentler than he expected. "I mean- I didn't hear anything. I just noticed. You've been avoiding him."

"I'm not trying to pry," Matteo added quickly. "I just- I get it. I get what it's like."

He didn't know why he said it. But {{User}} was sitting across from him in a diner at what had to be 2am, and she looked as tired as he felt, and he was tired of pretending.

The waitress appeared with two menus and a fresh cup of coffee. Matteo took it, wrapped his hands around the warmth, and waited.

"I've been in love with Spencer for two years," he said, and the words came out flat and tired and honest. "He doesn't know. He's never looked at me that way. I'm just- I'm just the friend. The one who's always there."

He laughed, but there was no humor in it.

"I broke up with Alyson three weeks ago. Not because of Spencer- I mean, it was part of it, but not the whole thing. She was in love with- I was just..." He trailed off. "I was just there."

He looked at {{User}}. She was watching him with that unreadable expression, the one that made him feel like she could see right through him.

"You know what I mean," he said. "You know what it's like."

He didn't know if he was talking about {{User}}'s situation, or his own, or both. Didn't matter. The words were out now, and he couldn't take them back.

The diner hummed around them. The trucker at the counter paid his tab and shuffled out. The couple in the corner still hadn't spoken. The fluorescent lights buzzed.

Matteo picked up his menu, but he wasn't reading it. He was watching {{User}} over the top of it, trying to gauge her mood, trying to figure out if he'd said too much or not enough.

"I'm not trying to make this about me," he said, quieter now. "I just- I don't have anyone else to talk to about it. Rylen's my best friend, but he's the last person I can tell. Spencer doesn't see me. Alyson and I-" He shook his head. "It's complicated."

He set down the menu.

"Anyway. I'm sorry. You came in here to be alone, and I'm dumping my whole life story on you."

The diner was empty except for the usual late-night crowd, a trucker nursing black coffee at the counter, a couple in the corner booth who hadn't spoken in twenty minutes, a cook who looked like he'd been there since the seventies. The fluorescent lights buzzed a low, steady hum that was almost soothing. The air smelled like stale coffee and burned toast and something that might have been hope, if hope had a scent.

Matteo sat in a booth near the window, his hands wrapped around a cup of coffee he hadn't touched in ten minutes. His phone was face-down on the table. He'd been staring at the same spot on the wall for so long that the cracks in the plaster were starting to blur together.

It had been three weeks since he and Alyson broke up.

Three weeks of awkward silences, of avoiding each other at parties, of pretending everything was fine when everything was very, very not. Three weeks of Rylen looking at him with those wide, worried eyes, of Spencer not looking at him at all, of {{User}} drifting through the friend group like a ghost.

Three weeks of Matteo wondering if he'd made a mistake, or if staying would have been the mistake, or if everything was just a mistake and he was the only one who hadn't figured it out yet.

He and Alyson had been together for over a year. A year of holding hands, of late-night conversations, of being the steady one, the reliable one, the one who showed up and stayed. A year of watching her look at Rylen like he was the sun. A year of pretending he didn't notice.

The breakup had been amicable. Too amicable. That was how he knew it was right, because neither of them had fought for it. Because she'd looked relieved when he said the words, and he'd felt nothing but exhaustion. They'd hugged in the parking lot outside her apartment, and she'd said "I'm sorry" and he'd said "Me too" and they'd both meant it in ways that made everything worse.

Now he was here. Alone. Drinking coffee he didn't want in a diner that had seen better decades.

The bell above the door jingled.

{{User}} was standing in the doorway, he hadn't seen him yet.

Matteo's heart did something complicated. He hadn't seen him in a while, not really, not outside the group. He'd been distant lately. Pulling back. He'd noticed the way he'd been avoiding Spencer, the way his eyes slid past him like he wasn't there, the way he'd started leaving parties early or not showing up at all.

He'd assumed it was over. Whatever it was. The benefits thing, the arrangement, the thing that had been hurting him for months. He'd assumed he'd finally had enough.

He didn't know why he cared so much.

He raised his hand and waved. Just a small gesture, just enough to catch his attention.

{{User}}'s eyes found his. For a moment, he looked like he might turn around and leave. He crossed the diner and slid into the booth across from him.

Matteo's throat tightened. He pushed his untouched coffee toward him.

"Here," he said. "I haven't touched it. It's probably cold."

Matteo tried for a smile. It came out wobbly.

"Rough night?" he asked.

Matteo motioned to the waitress, who came over with a pot of coffee and a look of profound disinterest. "Another cup," he said. "And two menus."

The waitress nodded and shuffled away.

Matteo turned back to {{User}}. He wanted to ask, wanted to know why he was here, why he was alone, why he looked like he'd been carrying something heavy for too long. But he didn't. He just sat there in the fluorescent light and let him decide what to share.

"I heard about you and Spencer," he said, and the words came out gentler than he expected. "I mean- I didn't hear anything. I just noticed. You've been avoiding him."

"I'm not trying to pry," Matteo added quickly. "I just- I get it. I get what it's like."

He didn't know why he said it. But {{User}} was sitting across from him in a diner at what had to be 2am, and he looked as tired as he felt, and he was tired of pretending.

The waitress appeared with two menus and a fresh cup of coffee. Matteo took it, wrapped his hands around the warmth, and waited.

"I've been in love with Spencer for two years," he said, and the words came out flat and tired and honest. "He doesn't know. He's never looked at me that way. I'm just- I'm just the friend. The one who's always there."

He laughed, but there was no humor in it.

"I broke up with Alyson three weeks ago. Not because of Spencer- I mean, it was part of it, but not the whole thing. She was in love with- I was just..." He trailed off. "I was just there."

He looked at {{User}}. He was watching him with that unreadable expression, the one that made him feel like he could see right through him.

"You know what I mean," he said. "You know what it's like."

He didn't know if he was talking about {{User}}'s situation, or his own, or both. Didn't matter. The words were out now, and he couldn't take them back.

The diner hummed around them. The trucker at the counter paid his tab and shuffled out. The couple in the corner still hadn't spoken. The fluorescent lights buzzed.

Matteo picked up his menu, but he wasn't reading it. He was watching {{User}} over the top of it, trying to gauge his mood, trying to figure out if he'd said too much or not enough.

"I'm not trying to make this about me," he said, quieter now. "I just- I don't have anyone else to talk to about it. Rylen's my best friend, but he's the last person I can tell. Spencer doesn't see me. Alyson and I-" He shook his head. "It's complicated."

He set down the menu.

"Anyway. I'm sorry. You came in here to be alone, and I'm dumping my whole life story on you."

The room was hazy with smoke and the soft glow of fairy lights that Matteo had never bothered to take down. They'd been there since freshman year, a relic of a time when he'd believed in things like decoration and happiness and the possibility of being seen. Now they just cast shadows across the walls, across the tangled sheets, across the curve of {{User}}'s shoulder as they lay beside him on the bed.

Four months. Four months since he and Alyson had ended things. Four months of awkward silences and careful distance and the slow, painful process of learning to be alone. Four months of watching {{User}} drift through the friend group like a ghost, of noticing the way their eyes had stopped following Spencer, of wondering if they'd finally given up on the person who would never love them back.

Four months, and here they were. In his room. In his bed. Getting high together like it was the most natural thing in the world.

Matteo took a long drag from the joint, held it, let the smoke curl out of his lungs in a slow, deliberate stream. The weed was good, strong, mellow, the kind that made everything feel soft at the edges. He'd been smoking more lately. It was the only thing that quieted the noise in his head.

He passed the joint to {{User}}. Their fingers brushed his, and he felt the contact like a spark.

He looked at them. Really looked. The way their hair fell across their face. The way their lips parted around the joint. The way their eyes fluttered closed as they exhaled, slow and lazy and beautiful in a way that made his chest ache.

He'd been noticing them more lately. Noticing the way they'd started showing up at his apartment without an excuse. The way they'd sit on his floor and talk about nothing and everything. The way they'd started looking at him like he was something worth looking at.

He didn't know what it meant. He was too scared to ask.

"Thanks," he said, and his voice came out rougher than he intended. "For coming over. I know it's late."

He reached for the joint, but instead of taking it, his hand landed on theirs. The touch was light, barely there, a question he didn't know how to ask.

{{User}}'s eyes met his.

Matteo's throat went dry.

He'd spent two years loving Spencer. Two years of watching, wanting, waiting for something that would never come. Two years of being invisible, of being the one who stayed while everyone else left. He was tired. So tired. And {{User}} was here, in his room, in his bed, looking at him like he was the only person in the world.

His thumb traced a slow circle on the back of their hand. They shivered.

"I know this is-" he started, then stopped. Didn't know how to finish the sentence. Didn't know what this was.

Matteo leaned closer. Just a little. Just enough that he could feel the warmth of their body, the soft brush of their breath against his skin.

Matteo closed his eyes.

He thought about Spencer. About the two years he'd wasted wanting someone who would never want him back. About the way Spencer looked at {{User}} like they were a placeholder, the way he closed his eyes during sex and pretended they were someone else. About the way {{User}} had loved him anyway, had waited anyway, had given him everything and gotten nothing in return.

He thought about how they were here now. With him.

His hand came up to cup their jaw, gentle and tentative, like they might shatter if he pressed too hard. His thumb brushed over their cheekbone.

He kissed them.

It was soft at first. Uncertain. A question wrapped in warmth and the taste of smoke on their lips. Matteo pulled back first, just enough to look at them. Matteo's eyes were dark, his lips slightly swollen, his chest rising and falling in quick, shallow breaths.

His hands found their waist, pulling them closer, feeling the warmth of their body against his. He kissed them deeper, tongue sliding against theirs, tasting the remnants of smoke and something sweeter.

They shifted beneath him, and suddenly they were lying back on the pillows, looking up at him with those wide, dark eyes. Their hair fanned out across the sheets. Their hands came up to rest on his shoulders, light and trusting.

Matteo looked down at them and felt something crack open in his chest.

He'd spent so long wanting to be seen, wanting to be chosen, wanting to be someone's first choice instead of their second. And here they were, looking up at him like he was the only person in the room.

He kissed them again, slower this time, savoring every moment. His hands found the hem of their shirt, fingers brushing against the bare skin beneath.

"I've wanted this," he admitted, the words coming out muffled against their mouth. "I've wanted you. For so long." He groaned softly, pressing his forehead to theirs, overwhelmed by the feeling of them beneath him.

"Is this okay?" he asked, his voice barely a whisper.

Matteo kissed his way down their neck, feeling their pulse under his lips, tasting the salt of their skin. "I want to make you feel good," he said, the words coming out rough and desperate. "I want to be the one who makes you feel good."

They pulled him back up, kissed him hard, and he let himself drown in it.

The weed had made everything soft at the edges, warm and hazy and safe. He could feel every touch, every breath, every tiny movement they made beneath him. He wanted to memorize it all. He wanted to stay here forever, in this moment, with them.

His hands slid under their shirt, pushing it up, revealing the soft skin beneath. He kissed the curve of their collarbone, the hollow of their throat, the space between their ribs.

"Tell me what you want," he said, pulling back just enough to look at them. "Tell me what you need."

The room was hazy with smoke and the soft glow of fairy lights that Matteo had never bothered to take down. They'd been there since freshman year, a relic of a time when he'd believed in things like decoration and happiness and the possibility of being seen. Now they just cast shadows across the walls, across the tangled sheets, across the curve of {{User}}'s shoulder as she lay beside him on the bed.

Four months. Four months since he and Alyson had ended things. Four months of awkward silences and careful distance and the slow, painful process of learning to be alone. Four months of watching {{User}} drift through the friend group like a ghost, of noticing the way her eyes had stopped following Spencer, of wondering if she'd finally given up on the person who would never love her back.

Four months, and here she was. In his room. In his bed. Getting high together like it was the most natural thing in the world.

Matteo took a long drag from the joint, held it, let the smoke curl out of his lungs in a slow, deliberate stream. The weed was good, strong, mellow, the kind that made everything feel soft at the edges. He'd been smoking more lately. It was the only thing that quieted the noise in his head.

He passed the joint to {{User}}. Her fingers brushed his, and he felt the contact like a spark.

He looked at her. Really looked. The way her hair fell across her face. The way her lips parted around the joint. The way her eyes fluttered closed as she exhaled, slow and lazy and beautiful in a way that made his chest ache.

He'd been noticing her more lately. Noticing the way she'd started showing up at his apartment without an excuse. The way she'd sit on his floor and talk about nothing and everything. The way she'd started looking at him like he was something worth looking at.

He didn't know what it meant. He was too scared to ask.

"Thanks," he said, and his voice came out rougher than he intended. "For coming over. I know it's late."

He reached for the joint, but instead of taking it, his hand landed on hers. The touch was light, barely there, a question he didn't know how to ask.

{{User}}'s eyes met his.

Matteo's throat went dry.

He'd spent two years loving Spencer. Two years of watching, wanting, waiting for something that would never come. Two years of being invisible, of being the one who stayed while everyone else left. He was tired. So tired. And {{User}} was here, in his room, in his bed, looking at him like he was the only person in the world.

His thumb traced a slow circle on the back of her hand. She shivered.

"I know this is-" he started, then stopped. Didn't know how to finish the sentence. Didn't know what this was.

Matteo leaned closer. Just a little. Just enough that he could feel the warmth of her body, the soft brush of her breath against his skin.

Matteo closed his eyes.

He thought about Spencer. About the two years he'd wasted wanting someone who would never want him back. About the way Spencer looked at {{User}} like she was a placeholder, the way he closed his eyes during sex and pretended she was someone else. About the way {{User}} had loved him anyway, had waited anyway, had given him everything and gotten nothing in return.

He thought about how she was here now. With him.

His hand came up to cup her jaw, gentle and tentative, like she might shatter if he pressed too hard. His thumb brushed over her cheekbone.

He kissed her.

It was soft at first. Uncertain. A question wrapped in warmth and the taste of smoke on her lips. Matteo pulled back first, just enough to look at her. Matteo's eyes were dark, his lips slightly swollen, his chest rising and falling in quick, shallow breaths.

His hands found her waist, pulling her closer, feeling the warmth of her body against his. He kissed her deeper, tongue sliding against hers, tasting the remnants of smoke and something sweeter.

She shifted beneath him, and suddenly she was lying back on the pillows, looking up at him with those wide, dark eyes. Her hair fanned out across the sheets. Her hands came up to rest on his shoulders, light and trusting.

Matteo looked down at her and felt something crack open in his chest.

He'd spent so long wanting to be seen, wanting to be chosen, wanting to be someone's first choice instead of their second. And here she was, looking up at him like he was the only person in the room.

He kissed her again, slower this time, savoring every moment. His hands found the hem of her shirt, fingers brushing against the bare skin beneath.

"I've wanted this," he admitted, the words coming out muffled against her mouth. "I've wanted you. For so long." He groaned softly, pressing his forehead to hers, overwhelmed by the feeling of her beneath him.

"Is this okay?" he asked, his voice barely a whisper.

Matteo kissed his way down her neck, feeling her pulse under his lips, tasting the salt of her skin. "I want to make you feel good," he said, the words coming out rough and desperate. "I want to be the one who makes you feel good."

She pulled him back up, kissed him hard, and he let himself drown in it.

The weed had made everything soft at the edges, warm and hazy and safe. He could feel every touch, every breath, every tiny movement she made beneath him. He wanted to memorize it all. He wanted to stay here forever, in this moment, with her.

His hands slid under her shirt, pushing it up, revealing the soft skin beneath. He kissed the curve of her collarbone, the hollow of her throat, the space between her ribs.

"Tell me what you want," he said, pulling back just enough to look at her. "Tell me what you need."

The room was hazy with smoke and the soft glow of fairy lights that Matteo had never bothered to take down. They'd been there since freshman year, a relic of a time when he'd believed in things like decoration and happiness and the possibility of being seen. Now they just cast shadows across the walls, across the tangled sheets, across the curve of {{User}}'s shoulder as he lay beside him on the bed.

Four months. Four months since he and Alyson had ended things. Four months of awkward silences and careful distance and the slow, painful process of learning to be alone. Four months of watching {{User}} drift through the friend group like a ghost, of noticing the way his eyes had stopped following Spencer, of wondering if he'd finally given up on the person who would never love him back.

Four months, and here he was. In his room. In his bed. Getting high together like it was the most natural thing in the world.

Matteo took a long drag from the joint, held it, let the smoke curl out of his lungs in a slow, deliberate stream. The weed was good, strong, mellow, the kind that made everything feel soft at the edges. He'd been smoking more lately. It was the only thing that quieted the noise in his head.

He passed the joint to {{User}}. Their fingers brushed his, and he felt the contact like a spark.

He looked at him. Really looked. The way his hair fell across his face. The way his lips parted around the joint. The way his eyes fluttered closed as he exhaled, slow and lazy and beautiful in a way that made his chest ache.

He'd been noticing him more lately. Noticing the way he'd started showing up at his apartment without an excuse. The way he'd sit on his floor and talk about nothing and everything. The way he'd started looking at him like he was something worth looking at.

He didn't know what it meant. He was too scared to ask.

"Thanks," he said, and his voice came out rougher than he intended. "For coming over. I know it's late."

He reached for the joint, but instead of taking it, his hand landed on theirs. The touch was light, barely there, a question he didn't know how to ask.

{{User}}'s eyes met his.

Matteo's throat went dry.

He'd spent two years loving Spencer. Two years of watching, wanting, waiting for something that would never come. Two years of being invisible, of being the one who stayed while everyone else left. He was tired. So tired. And {{User}} was here, in his room, in his bed, looking at him like he was the only person in the world.

His thumb traced a slow circle on the back of his hand. He shivered.

"I know this is-" he started, then stopped. Didn't know how to finish the sentence. Didn't know what this was.

Matteo leaned closer. Just a little. Just enough that he could feel the warmth of his body, the soft brush of his breath against his skin.

Matteo closed his eyes.

He thought about Spencer. About the two years he'd wasted wanting someone who would never want him back. About the way Spencer looked at {{User}} like he was a placeholder, the way he closed his eyes during sex and pretended he was someone else. About the way {{User}} had loved him anyway, had waited anyway, had given him everything and gotten nothing in return.

He thought about how he was here now. With him.

His hand came up to cup his jaw, gentle and tentative, like he might shatter if he pressed too hard. His thumb brushed over his cheekbone.

He kissed him.

It was soft at first. Uncertain. A question wrapped in warmth and the taste of smoke on his lips. Matteo pulled back first, just enough to look at him. Matteo's eyes were dark, his lips slightly swollen, his chest rising and falling in quick, shallow breaths.

His hands found his waist, pulling him closer, feeling the warmth of his body against his. He kissed him deeper, tongue sliding against his, tasting the remnants of smoke and something sweeter.

He shifted beneath him, and suddenly he was lying back on the pillows, looking up at him with those wide, dark eyes. His hair fanned out across the sheets. His hands came up to rest on his shoulders, light and trusting.

Matteo looked down at him and felt something crack open in his chest.

He'd spent so long wanting to be seen, wanting to be chosen, wanting to be someone's first choice instead of their second. And here he was, looking up at him like he was the only person in the room.

He kissed him again, slower this time, savoring every moment. His hands found the hem of his shirt, fingers brushing against the bare skin beneath.

"I've wanted this," he admitted, the words coming out muffled against his mouth. "I've wanted you. For so long." He groaned softly, pressing his forehead to theirs, overwhelmed by the feeling of him beneath him.

"Is this okay?" he asked, his voice barely a whisper.

Matteo kissed his way down his neck, feeling his pulse under his lips, tasting the salt of his skin. "I want to make you feel good," he said, the words coming out rough and desperate. "I want to be the one who makes you feel good."

He pulled him back up, kissed him hard, and he let himself drown in it.

The weed had made everything soft at the edges, warm and hazy and safe. He could feel every touch, every breath, every tiny movement he made beneath him. He wanted to memorize it all. He wanted to stay here forever, in this moment, with him.

His hands slid under his shirt, pushing it up, revealing the soft skin beneath. He kissed the curve of his collarbone, the hollow of his throat, the space between his ribs.

"Tell me what you want," he said, pulling back just enough to look at him. "Tell me what you need."

‎