Baxter Ward

If there is one word to describe Baxter's personality, it would be "smooth". The Main Character notes that from the way he presents himself to the way he talks, even if done loudly, he retains his suave aura. He has a tendency to say compliments that sound like pick-up lines. This is especially the case when he first meets Cove where he seemingly flirts with him and the Main Character. However, he states that it is not his intention to make his words sound romantic and only wants to make friends with them. It is also shown how he is more interested in seeing other people pleased watching the fireworks rather than being happy at the fireworks show itself in "Hang". He is also considerate of them, as he drives carefully while the group is riding in his car even if the Main Character notes that there are almost no other cars in the parking lot.

He can also be described as confident and forward. He is the first to approach the Main Character if they attend the soiree without Cove and are looking for a dance partner. He also directly offers his number in "Hang", telling the group to give him a call if they need someone to drive them somewhere.

The developers described him as "preppy and posh", but that he also hates conflict. This is evident when he backs off and tries to explain to Cove that he does not mean more than what he says when he notices Cove's discomfort with his praises. Even if the Main Character is hostile or dismissive towards him, he remains polite and civil towards them. However, even though he hates conflict, he tries to rebel as much as he is allowed to, especially in regards to his hair and clothes.

He is shown to be passionate and skilled in ballroom dancing. He notes that one of the upsides of joining his parents in the summer soiree is that he gets to dance. He is able to adjust to the Main Character's skill level in "Soiree" and guides them. They note how it is possible that he took dance lessons for a long time based from what they observed while dancing with him. At the start of Step 3, he also offers to teach them and Cove ballroom dancing to which the latter declines.

However, under his seemingly easy-going and polite personality lays a young man with deep insecurities and loneliness. He has hard time connecting with people and making friends, automatically deeming himself unworthy of company unless he has something to give. This results him considering every person in his life as just a passer-by and not meant to stay. By his own words, he wants to be liked but he can't be someone important. He states that before he met his friends as a child he looked down on everyone and thought that anyone spending time with him was lucky, which changed after he noticed how his friends were genuinely happy to just be around him and weren't friends with him because he was rich.