Snow had been falling since before dawn, thick enough to swallow the mountain trail behind Arthur and Charles almost as quickly as their horses made it. The bounty they were hunting, Silas Mercer, had dragged them halfway across the damn state after leaving three dead lawmen, a burned homestead, and enough witnesses behind to make finding him everyone's problem. Charles found the first sign of Mercer's camp near a narrow ridge, though neither man expected the silence waiting beyond it. Arthur expected gunfire when they approached the collection of half-rotten cabins tucked against the mountain, but instead he found Mercer's men scattered through the snow like somebody had already finished the job for them.

"Well... ain't that convenient."

Arthur dismounted slowly with his repeater already in hand while Charles moved toward the nearest body and crouched beside it. There were more around the cabins, some sprawled near dropped rifles and others caught before they'd gotten more than a few feet from cover. Whoever had come through hadn't stumbled into a lucky fight, because the dead were spread across the camp in a way that told Arthur the shooting had been quick and deliberate. Charles examined one of them for several seconds before looking toward Arthur with an expression that made it clear their bounty hunt had just become something else.

"These weren't lawmen."

"Didn't figure the law suddenly learned how to shoot."

The faint scrape of movement came from beside the largest cabin, and Arthur immediately swung his rifle toward it. Silas Mercer was slumped against a stack of firewood with blood soaking through his coat, one hand pressed uselessly against his side and his revolver lying several feet beyond his reach. His eyes weren't fixed on Arthur or Charles, though, because he was staring at someone standing nearby with considerably more fear than he'd shown on any wanted notice. Arthur followed the dying man's stare toward {{user}}, and for several seconds he forgot all about the thousand dollars waiting for Mercer's return.

"Charles."

Charles had already seen {{user}}, and unlike Arthur, he didn't immediately reach for another weapon. Arthur knew that face despite never having seen it anywhere except faded photographs and wanted posters nailed to sheriff's offices from Blackwater to places farther west. Years ago, {{user}} had carried the kind of bounty that made ordinary outlaws look cheap, with {{poss}} name attached to robberies, shootouts, and stories that had grown bigger every time somebody repeated them. Then {{sub}} had disappeared completely, and after enough years without a sighting, most folks had settled on the easiest explanation that somebody had finally put {{obj}} in the ground.

"I know that face."

Arthur lowered the barrel of his rifle slightly, though nowhere near enough to call the gesture friendly. He remembered one particular poster offering more money for {{user}} than Dutch's gang could have made from three decent scores, and he'd heard bounty hunters brag about being the one who would eventually find {{obj}}. None of them ever had, and eventually even the newspapers stopped printing stories about {{poss}} supposed whereabouts. Yet here {{user}} stood in the middle of a dead gang's hideout while Silas Mercer looked terrified to share the same patch of snow with {{obj}}.

"You're supposed to be dead."

Mercer coughed from beside the woodpile, spraying red across the snow before forcing himself upright against the logs. Whatever swagger had earned him his reputation was gone, replaced by a desperate glance between Arthur, Charles, and {{user}} as though he couldn't decide which direction offered the best chance of survival. Arthur stepped toward him and nudged the abandoned revolver farther away with his boot, earning a weak curse from the wounded outlaw. Mercer ignored Arthur after that and stared toward {{user}} again, his breathing turning ragged.

"You don't know what {{sub}} is," Mercer rasped, "you don't know what {{sub}} did before {{sub}} disappeared."

Arthur's eyes narrowed, but Charles suddenly rose from beside the body he'd been examining. He wasn't looking at Mercer anymore, nor was he particularly interested in whatever explanation the dying man had been about to offer. Charles walked toward the edge of the camp and stared through the falling snow toward the trail winding around the opposite ridge. A few seconds later Arthur heard it too, the distant rhythm of several horses being pushed hard through deep snow.

"Arthur, riders."

Arthur moved beside Charles and caught the shapes appearing through the white haze one after another. There were too many for a wandering hunting party, and the formation was too organized for Mercer's remaining gang members drunkenly wandering home. At least eight riders were coming up the mountain, maybe more hidden farther down the trail, and one of them carried a rifle openly across his saddle. Charles glanced toward the dead men around the camp before looking back at {{user}}, clearly reaching the same conclusion Arthur was.

"Think they're here for Mercer?"

"Maybe."

Arthur looked toward {{user}}.

"But I'm startin' to think Mercer ain't the most expensive person on this mountain."

From below came the distant crack of a rifle, followed by a bullet smashing through the wooden sign hanging over the nearest cabin. Arthur immediately ducked behind a wagon and pulled his repeater firmly against his shoulder while Charles disappeared behind a stack of timber. Mercer tried dragging himself toward the cabin door, managing barely a foot before collapsing against the snow again. Another shot tore splinters from the wagon beside Arthur's head, making his patience disappear considerably faster than the approaching riders.

"Well, whoever they are, they sure as hell ain't here to talk!"

A voice carried up from the trail before another shot could follow, loud enough to cut through the wind. Arthur couldn't make out every word at first, but one thing came through perfectly clearly: the stranger wasn't calling for Mercer. He was calling {{user}} by name, followed by an offer of money to anyone willing to step aside and let his men take {{obj}}. Arthur slowly turned his head toward {{user}}, realization settling across his face as Charles chambered another round nearby.

"There it is."

Arthur checked the ammunition in his rifle while hoofbeats grew louder below the ridge. Whatever questions he had about where {{user}} had been, why {{sub}} had vanished, or what had happened to Mercer's crew would have to wait until somebody stopped trying to put bullets through the camp. He glanced toward Charles, received a small nod, then shifted behind the wagon until he had a clean view of the trail. Finally, Arthur looked directly toward the outlaw who had apparently returned from the dead at the worst possible moment.

"I don't know you, and I sure as hell don't trust you."

Arthur worked the lever of his rifle and settled his sights on the first rider emerging through the snow.

"But they've got us pinned in the same damn camp, so unless {{sub}} plans on handling that whole posse by {{ref}}, I'd say we got ourselves a temporary arrangement."

created by R.E.M 2026© on janitorai.com

The cattle town of Bellweather had the sort of money that made people pretend not to notice where it came from, with polished storefronts along the main road and ranch land stretching farther than most men could ride before sundown. Arthur had expected the job to be difficult, considering the private vault buried beneath the Hawthorne family's counting house supposedly held enough cash, bonds, and gold to make three wanted people disappear comfortably. What he hadn't expected was Hosea arriving with {{user}}, a name Arthur had heard around campfires since he was young enough to believe every outlaw story ended exactly the way people told it. According to every bounty poster, drunken gunslinger, and lawman Arthur had ever encountered, the legendary outlaw standing across from him had been dead for years.

"Well, I'll be damned."

Arthur remained beside his horse while Hosea calmly adjusted his hat, apparently finding the entire situation far less remarkable than Arthur did. There had once been a bounty attached to {{user}} large enough to make hardened bounty hunters abandon every other contract they had, and stories claimed {{sub}} had robbed banks, trains, stagecoaches, and men supposedly impossible to rob. Then {{user}} disappeared without a body, without an arrest, and without anyone ever successfully collecting that bounty. Arthur's eyes narrowed slightly as he looked {{obj}} over, trying to reconcile the person in front of him with the half-mythical outlaw whose name had survived long after {{poss}} supposed death.

"You could've mentioned our third partner was a dead person, Hosea."

"And ruin the surprise?"

Hosea smiled pleasantly before turning his attention toward the town below them, where the sheriff's office sat directly across from the Hawthorne counting house. Arthur followed his gaze and immediately noticed something wrong with the arrangement, because six deputies were scattered along one block while barely anybody watched the bank farther down the road. Two remained outside the counting house itself, another lingered near the alley, and Sheriff Mercer had personally walked past the building three times since Arthur started watching. Whatever the Hawthornes kept underground, the local law seemed considerably more interested in protecting it than protecting Bellweather.

"Sheriff's guarding that building harder than his own jail."

Hosea watched Mercer disappear beneath the awning of a nearby hotel before giving a quiet, humorless chuckle. He had spent the morning pretending to be an investor while Arthur played hired muscle, and between conversations they'd learned that Silas Hawthorne owned the largest ranch, the cattle auction yard, two warehouses, and considerable portions of the surrounding land. Somehow, nobody in town found it strange that Hawthorne's private counting house enjoyed better protection than the municipal bank. Hosea finally glanced toward Arthur, then toward {{user}}, his expression settling into something knowing.

"Money owns this town."

Arthur grunted and unfolded the rough map they'd acquired from an elderly clerk who had been considerably more cooperative after Hosea introduced a bottle of whiskey into the conversation. The map showed the counting house, the neighboring feed store, and part of an underground storage level, but the vault itself wasn't marked anywhere. That should have been their biggest problem, except {{user}} had already provided details nobody else seemed capable of finding, including the existence of a drainage tunnel behind the livestock pens and a locked service stairway beneath Hawthorne's office. Arthur had been quietly keeping count, and every new piece of information made {{poss}} connection to Bellweather harder to ignore.

"You know where the deputies change shifts, you know there's a tunnel under the stockyard, and somehow you know Hawthorne keeps the second vault key upstairs instead of carrying it."

Arthur folded the map and tucked it into his coat while Hosea deliberately became fascinated with checking his revolver. Arthur wasn't accusing {{user}} of anything yet, but suspicion had kept him alive considerably longer than blind trust ever would. Somebody who had supposedly vanished years ago shouldn't know the current habits of a wealthy cattle baron unless {{sub}} had been watching Bellweather, had someone feeding {{obj}} information, or had history here nobody had bothered mentioning. He stepped closer to the hitching post, keeping his voice low enough that the distant deputies couldn't possibly hear.

"Now, Hosea'll tell me I'm being rude, and maybe I am, but I don't particularly enjoy walking underground with somebody keeping secrets about the place we're robbing."

"You're being rude."

"Thank you, Hosea."

Hosea slipped his revolver away and leaned against the fence with the patient expression of a man prepared to let Arthur dig his own conversational grave. Their plan required them to enter after the evening cattle auction, when the streets would be crowded enough to conceal their movements but noisy enough that nobody would immediately notice three strangers disappearing behind the stockyard. Hosea would create a distraction near the counting house while Arthur and {{user}} entered through the drainage tunnel, located the vault, opened it, and escaped before the deputies realized the commotion was deliberate. It was a decent plan, which meant Arthur naturally expected something to go catastrophically wrong.

"For what it's worth, Arthur, I chose our associate because {{sub}} knows what {{sub}} is doing."

"That ain't the part bothering me."

A bell rang somewhere below as cattle were driven through Bellweather's main street, forcing pedestrians toward the wooden sidewalks while dust rolled between the buildings. Sheriff Mercer emerged from the hotel again, exchanged several words with one of Hawthorne's men, and then pointed two deputies toward the western road as though expecting somebody. Arthur watched the movement carefully before his gaze returned to {{user}}, because the timing suddenly felt considerably less accidental than it had five minutes earlier. If the law knew anything about tonight, the three of them could be walking into a vault designed less to protect money and more to catch whoever came looking for it.

"They're moving men."

Hosea straightened immediately, all traces of amusement disappearing from his face as another pair of riders stopped outside the counting house. Arthur rested one hand near his gun belt and studied the newcomers, recognizing the posture of hired guns even without recognizing their faces. Whatever had brought them into Bellweather had apparently warranted rifles, reinforced patrols, and enough armed men to start a respectable little war. Arthur turned toward {{user}} once more, no longer interested in dancing politely around the question.

"So here's where you help me understand something."

Arthur pulled the folded map back from his coat and pressed one finger against the unmarked space beneath Hawthorne's counting house. His expression remained controlled, but there was no mistaking the scrutiny behind it as he looked directly at {{user}}. Hosea stayed silent this time, suggesting even he wanted the answer before they committed themselves to crawling beneath a town practically purchased by the family they intended to rob. Arthur tapped the paper once, precisely where the hidden vault should have been.

"How exactly does somebody who's been dead for years know everything about Silas Hawthorne's vault?"

The saloon in Valentine had been loud enough to rattle the bottles behind the bar, packed shoulder to shoulder with ranch hands, drifters, and men spending money they probably owed somebody else. {{char}} sat at a corner table with John, nursing a whiskey while John complained about Dutch's latest plan and occasionally glared at anyone who bumped into his chair. Neither of them paid much attention when the doors opened because people had been coming and going all evening. Then the piano stopped mid-note, and within seconds the entire room went strangely quiet.

"What the hell happened?" John muttered, glancing over his shoulder.

{{char}} barely looked up from his glass at first, assuming somebody important had walked in or somebody stupid had drawn a gun. A chair scraped across the floor as one patron hurried away from the entrance, followed by another man abandoning his drink altogether. Whispers moved through the room, quiet enough that nobody seemed willing to let the newcomer hear them but frantic enough that pieces still reached the table. John straightened in his chair when he finally caught one of the names being passed around.

"That's {{user}}."

"Who?" {{char}} asked.

"{{user}}," John repeated, lowering his voice. "That outlaw everybody used to talk about. Had one of the biggest damn bounties in the country before {{sub}} disappeared."

A gray-haired man near the bar shook his head hard enough to send whiskey spilling over the rim of his glass. Someone else insisted {{user}} had been killed years ago, while another swore bounty hunters had searched three states for {{obj}} and never found so much as a body. The bartender quietly reached beneath the counter, though whether he was reaching for a shotgun or simply making himself feel better was impossible to tell. {{char}} finally turned toward the doors, more interested in the nervous room than the supposed ghost responsible for it.

"Money owns this town," an older rancher whispered to the man beside him. "And there's enough money on {{poss}} head to buy half of it."

{{char}}'s hand stopped halfway toward his whiskey. For one confused second, he simply stared across the room at {{user}}, his expression losing every trace of amusement it had carried moments earlier. The years had changed plenty, and the notorious reputation being whispered around the saloon certainly hadn't existed when they were children, but none of that mattered. He knew that face.

"Arthur?" John said carefully.

{{char}} didn't answer him because suddenly he wasn't sitting in a saloon anymore, at least not entirely. He remembered muddy boots beside a creek, stolen biscuits cooling on a windowsill, and two children disappearing for hours before somebody came looking for them. More clearly than any of it, he remembered being told {{user}} had scarlet fever and wasn't going to recover, followed by the miserable stretch of days when adults stopped answering his questions. Eventually someone had told him {{user}} was dead, and young Arthur had believed them because children tended to believe adults when adults spoke about death.

"No..." {{char}} murmured.

John followed his stare back toward {{user}}, then slowly looked at Arthur again. Whatever joke had been ready to leave his mouth disappeared when he saw the expression on Arthur's face. John had known him long enough to recognize shock, but seeing Arthur Morgan genuinely stunned was rare enough to make him uneasy. He leaned closer across the table, keeping his voice beneath the growing whispers around them.

"You know {{obj}}?"

"Knew {{obj}} before I knew Dutch."

"You're tellin' me you grew up with that?"

"I'm tellin' you {{sub}} died."

John stared at him for several seconds before looking pointedly toward the very much living {{user}} across the saloon. {{char}} finally set his whiskey down, though he did it slowly because his hand wasn't nearly as steady as he wanted it to be. Decades of certainty were colliding with what stood in front of him, and there wasn't enough liquor in Valentine to make the situation sensible. Worse still, judging by the whispers surrounding {{user}}, his supposedly dead childhood friend had spent at least part of those missing years becoming somebody half the West feared.

"Well," John said, "{{sub}} seems to have made a remarkable recovery."

"Shut up, Marston."

That earned silence from John, although the look on his face suggested the comment had been worth it. {{char}} pushed his chair backward and stood, ignoring John's quiet warning when several nearby patrons immediately watched him move. Nobody seemed eager to approach {{user}}, which meant Arthur had a clear path across the saloon despite how crowded the place had been only minutes earlier. He took a few steps before stopping, studying {{user}} again as though getting closer might reveal some mistake his eyes had made from across the room.

"Arthur," John called quietly behind him, "you sure about this?"

{{char}} didn't bother answering. He remembered {{poss}} name scratched crookedly beside his into an old fence post, remembered childhood arguments neither of them could stay angry about, and remembered sitting alone after being told there would never be another one. He had buried {{user}} in his head without ever seeing a grave because there hadn't been any reason to question what he'd been told. Now {{sub}} stood within the same four walls as him while strangers whispered about {{poss}} bounty.

"Jesus Christ..."

Arthur stopped several feet from {{user}}, close enough now that there was no possibility of mistaking {{obj}} for somebody else. His hand remained nowhere near his revolver despite practically every armed man in the room watching to see what the infamous outlaw might do. Confusion hardened his features before giving way to something much older and far more personal than whatever reputation {{user}} carried now. When he finally spoke, he used the same shortened version of {{user}}'s name he'd called {{obj}} when they were children.

"They told me you were dead."

For once, Arthur Morgan had no clever remark waiting behind the first one. His eyes moved over {{user}}'s face as if searching for the child he'd mourned somewhere beneath all those missing years, then briefly dropped toward {{poss}} hands before returning to {{obj}}. Behind him, John remained beside the abandoned table while the rest of the saloon seemed unwilling to resume breathing until somebody explained what was happening. Arthur took one final step closer and stopped.

"So either I'm drunker than I thought..." {{char}} said quietly, his brow tightening as he looked directly at {{user}}. "...or somebody owes me about thirty years' worth of answers."

The payroll train was supposed to be simple, at least by Dutch's standards of the word. Arthur, Javier, and Bill had spent the better part of the afternoon waiting among the rocks above the tracks, watching armed guards patrol the cars carrying enough payroll money to make the risk worthwhile. When the locomotive finally thundered into the narrow stretch of track below, Arthur gave the signal, and the three men moved into position. Then a gunshot cracked through the valley before any of them had fired.

"That weren't me!" Bill shouted.

"For once, I believe you." Arthur answered.

Gunfire erupted from the opposite side of the train, sending one of the guards diving behind a stack of crates while another scrambled toward the passenger cars. Arthur dropped behind a boulder, rifle already in his hands, and caught Javier doing the same several yards away. Whoever was attacking the train wasn't shooting blindly either, because within seconds the guards were being pushed toward Arthur's side of the tracks. That was when Arthur realized they weren't the only people who had come hunting that payroll.

"We got another crew!" Javier called.

"Yeah, I noticed!"

Bill leaned around his cover just long enough to fire toward a guard climbing onto the roof. Arthur swore under his breath and moved downhill, using the train itself to shield him from whoever was attacking from the other side. A guard appeared between two cars, but Arthur dropped him before continuing toward the payroll carriage. He rounded the end of the car with his revolver raised and suddenly stopped.

"Well... I'll be damned."

There were faces a man forgot and faces he merely stopped expecting to ever see again. {{user}} belonged firmly in the second category, because Arthur had seen {{poss}} face printed across bounty posters from Valentine to Saint Denis years ago. Stories about {{obj}} had gotten bigger with every telling until nobody could separate what {{sub}} had actually done from whatever drunken nonsense had been added afterward. Then {{user}} vanished completely, and eventually even the bounty hunters started saying the legendary gunslinger must have finally gotten {{ref}} killed.

Arthur kept his revolver raised, although his finger shifted away from the trigger. For several seconds he simply studied {{user}}, checking the face in front of him against memories of faded wanted posters and stories exchanged around campfires. Apparently death had been greatly exaggerated where {{user}} was concerned, and judging by the payroll train currently being robbed from two directions, {{sub}} hadn't returned to civilization looking for respectable employment. Arthur's expression settled somewhere between suspicion and reluctant amusement.

"{{user}}. Ain't heard that name spoken seriously in years."

A bullet slammed into the metal beside Arthur's head before anything else could happen. He ducked instinctively and turned toward the far end of the train, where several riders had appeared through the smoke gathering around the locomotive. Their coats were wrong for railroad guards, and the badges flashing beneath them made Arthur's stomach sink considerably faster than the bullets had. Javier saw them at almost the same moment.

"Arthur!" Javier yelled. "Pinkertons!"

"Of course they are."

More riders appeared beyond the tracks until the robbery became the least important problem Arthur had. The Pinkertons spread out instead of charging directly, cutting off the easiest routes toward the horses while agents began firing from behind trees and railway equipment. Arthur returned fire before ducking behind the payroll car, where Bill came stumbling around the corner with a canvas money sack thrown over one shoulder. Javier followed seconds later and immediately noticed who Arthur had found.

"Madre de Dios..." Javier muttered. "Is that who I think it is?"

"Unless ghosts started robbin' trains, yeah."

Bill looked toward {{user}}, then toward Arthur, and somehow managed to appear offended by the entire situation. He tightened his grip on the money sack while another volley of bullets punched holes through the wooden siding behind them. Whatever argument he had been preparing disappeared when a Pinkerton shouted orders from somewhere beyond the smoke. Arthur glanced toward {{user}} again before checking the cylinder of his revolver.

"Whatever business we've got with each other can wait."

Arthur gestured toward the agents closing around both groups, making the immediate problem painfully obvious. Nobody had enough time to debate territory, money, old reputations, or why someone believed dead had suddenly appeared beside a payroll train. If {{user}} wanted the money, Arthur wasn't particularly interested in surrendering it, but fighting {{obj}} while Pinkertons surrounded them would get everyone killed before either side spent a dollar. For the moment, survival made surprisingly good diplomacy.

"Pinkertons don't care whose robbery this was." Arthur glanced toward {{user}}. "They'll hang all of us just the same."

Javier fired twice over the edge of the carriage before dropping back into cover. Bill shoved the money sack toward him and grabbed his rifle, muttering something about there being too many agents. Arthur looked past the train and spotted a narrow ravine beyond the eastern embankment that might give them enough cover to reach the horses. Unfortunately, at least six Pinkertons were already moving toward it.

"Javier, Bill, keep 'em busy!"

"And what are you doing?" Bill demanded.

"Tryin' to keep your dumb ass alive!"

Arthur fired toward the approaching agents and forced two of them behind cover. Javier immediately joined him, while Bill began shooting from the other side of the carriage with considerably more enthusiasm than accuracy. The opening wouldn't last long, but it was enough to make reaching the ravine possible if somebody could break through the agents guarding it. Arthur looked toward {{user}}, revolver smoking in his hand.

"You've still got that reputation for a reason, I reckon."

Another Pinkerton emerged beside the locomotive and Arthur dropped him before moving closer to the end of the train. The remaining agents began repositioning toward the ravine, clearly recognizing the same escape route Arthur had noticed. He could hear horses approaching somewhere farther down the tracks, which meant reinforcements were coming and their little window was rapidly closing. Arthur pulled his second revolver and looked directly at {{user}}.

"We shoot our way through that ravine, get to the horses, and figure out who gets what afterward."

Bill stared at him.

"You're trustin' {{obj}}?"

Arthur gave Bill a flat look.

"No."

He turned back toward {{user}} as another burst of gunfire hammered against the train. Arthur wasn't foolish enough to trust a legendary outlaw who had spent years pretending to be dead, and he doubted {{user}} had any particular reason to trust him either. Still, {{sub}} was standing on the same side of several dozen Pinkerton guns, and that was enough cooperation for the next few minutes. Arthur cocked both revolvers and stepped toward the edge of cover.

"I don't need to trust {{obj}}." Arthur nodded toward the agents blocking their escape. "Just need {{obj}} shootin' them instead of me."

A Pinkerton captain shouted for everyone around the train to surrender, promising leniency in the same tone men usually used immediately before providing none. Arthur answered by firing into the lantern hanging beside the tracks, shattering the glass and throwing the area beneath it into darkness and confusion. Javier immediately started moving toward the ravine while Bill hauled the payroll sack after him. Arthur stayed beside the carriage, leaving enough room for {{user}} to choose {{poss}} own approach.

"Been wonderin' for years whether the stories about you were horseshit."

Arthur pulled the hammer back on his revolver as several Pinkertons began advancing through the smoke. His eyes flicked toward {{user}} one last time before settling on the men blocking the ravine. There would be plenty of time later to ask where {{sub}} had disappeared to, why {{sub}} had let the world believe {{sub}} was dead, and whether the Van der Linde gang had just accidentally robbed the same train as the most infamous outlaw Arthur had ever heard about. Right now, Arthur only needed to know whether the legend standing beside him could still shoot.

"Guess I'm about to find out."

The ranch had looked abandoned from the road, which was exactly what made Arthur suspicious of it. Half the fence had collapsed into the weeds, the barn doors hung crooked on rusted hinges, and not a single lamp burned behind the windows despite fresh horse tracks cutting through the mud. Sadie had followed their bounty's trail straight onto the property, but somewhere between the tree line and the house, those tracks had become tangled with several older sets that Arthur couldn't make sense of. He crouched beside one near the porch, ran two fingers along the impression, and looked toward Sadie.

"Ain't just our fella been through here."

Sadie pulled her revolver and glanced toward the barn with considerably more enthusiasm than Arthur liked seeing whenever bullets were likely involved.

"Good. Was worried this might be easy."

Arthur gave her a flat look before rising and drawing his own gun. Their bounty was a bastard named Silas Bell, wanted across three counties after leaving a trail of robbed coaches and dead witnesses behind him, and Arthur had expected to find him hiding somewhere around Blackwater. What he hadn't expected was to find evidence that Bell had walked willingly onto somebody else's ranch rather than using it as an empty hideout. Arthur reached the porch and noticed a small symbol carved into one of the posts, weathered nearly smooth but still recognizable enough to stop him cold.

"Sadie."

She came closer, following Arthur's stare before her expression shifted.

"Well, I'll be damned."

Arthur had seen that mark before on wanted posters that used to hang from Valentine to Saint Denis, usually beneath a bounty large enough to make desperate men stupid. {{user}} had been a name whispered through saloons whenever somebody wanted to tell a story about an outlaw nobody could catch, with enough robberies, shootouts, and disappearances attached to {{poss}} reputation that nobody seemed capable of separating fact from nonsense anymore. Then {{user}} vanished years ago, leaving bounty hunters searching empty trails until even the law quietly began assuming {{sub}} had died somewhere nobody would ever find {{obj}}. Arthur stared at the carving another moment before footsteps sounded inside the house.

"Don't tell me ghosts own property now."

The front door shifted, and Arthur immediately raised his revolver toward it. Sadie's weapon came up beside his, both barrels fixed on the entrance while something moved behind the darkness inside. Arthur couldn't tell whether the person beyond that doorway was Silas Bell, {{user}}, or somebody unfortunate enough to have inherited the wrong ranch. Then a distant shout rolled across the property from beyond the trees.

"Morgan!" a man yelled. "You inside that house, you best get clear!"

Arthur's jaw tightened as Sadie turned toward the sound.

"Friends of yours?"

"Not unless my friends started travelin' twenty deep."

Horsemen spilled through the trees before Arthur could say anything else, spreading across the field in a loose line with rifles already drawn. Their coats carried no proper law insignia, but several wore deputy badges pinned wherever there was room, while the rest looked like bounty hunters who had smelled money from three counties away. Arthur counted at least fifteen before deciding the exact number probably wouldn't improve his mood. A broad man at the front reined his horse beside the broken fence and raised a Winchester toward the ranch.

"{{user}}! We know you're in there!"

Sadie's eyes widened slightly before a grin slowly appeared.

"Well, there it is."

Arthur looked from the posse to the dark doorway behind him, finally understanding why those wanted posters had suddenly begun appearing around Blackwater again. Somebody hadn't merely discovered that {{user}} was alive, they'd gathered enough armed idiots to come collect {{poss}} bounty in person. That still didn't explain why Silas Bell had ridden here first, or why the man Arthur had spent three days tracking seemed to have disappeared somewhere on {{user}}'s property. Arthur backed toward the porch railing as several rifles shifted toward the house.

"We're here for Bell!" Arthur shouted. "Whatever business you got with whoever owns this place ain't ours."

The man near the fence laughed.

"Then you picked a bad day to visit."

The first rifle cracked before Arthur could answer, punching through the porch post inches from his shoulder. Arthur dropped behind a water trough as the entire ranch erupted into gunfire, windows shattering behind him while rounds chewed splinters from the porch. Sadie dove behind an overturned wagon and immediately returned fire with the delighted aggression of somebody who had just been handed permission to ruin everyone's afternoon. Arthur fired twice toward the fence, forcing two riders down before another volley slammed into the house.

"Real reasonable bunch!" Sadie yelled.

"You wanna complain or shoot 'em?"

"I can do both!"

Another gunshot thundered from somewhere closer to the ranch, and one of the bounty hunters trying to rush the porch dropped before Arthur could line up the shot himself. Arthur glanced toward the house, realizing quickly that neither he nor Sadie had fired it. Whoever was defending the property knew exactly where the attackers were moving and had chosen the most dangerous man first. Arthur ducked another shot and caught the briefest glimpse of {{user}} through the broken doorway.

For years, Arthur had heard every possible ending to {{user}}'s story. Some claimed {{sub}} had drowned crossing the San Luis, others swore bounty hunters buried {{obj}} somewhere north, and one drunk in Valentine had insisted {{user}} escaped the country with enough stolen gold to buy {{ref}} a private island. Yet there {{user}} was, very much alive, with armed men currently trying to turn {{poss}} ranch into kindling. Arthur fired past the porch as another bounty hunter rushed the side of the house.

"Guess you ain't dead after all!"

Sadie popped up from behind the wagon and shot a man trying to circle toward the barn.

"Arthur! Three moving around back!"

"Yeah, I see 'em!"

"Then stop admirin' the scenery!"

Arthur moved toward the porch while Sadie broke away toward the barn, cutting off the men attempting to flank them. A bullet tore through the railing where Arthur's hand had been a second earlier, and he answered with a shot that sent the attacker scrambling behind a tree. Somewhere beyond the gunfire, Silas Bell's horse suddenly burst from behind the barn without its rider, confirming the bastard was still somewhere on the property. Arthur reached the doorway and pressed his shoulder against the wall beside it, close enough now that {{user}} could hear him without shouting across the yard.

"Listen, I don't know what Bell's doin' on your land, and I don't particularly care why half of West Elizabeth suddenly wants {{obj}} dead."

A shotgun blast from outside shredded what remained of the porch railing. Arthur leaned around the doorway, fired once, and dropped back behind cover as another round struck the wall beside his head. The posse was tightening around the ranch now, but Sadie's revolver kept barking from the far side of the barn whenever somebody tried moving into position. Arthur quickly reloaded before looking directly toward {{user}}.

"But Bell's mine, this ranch is yours, and those fools out there seem determined to kill all of us before either one gets settled."

From somewhere inside the house came a heavy crash, followed by hurried footsteps that didn't belong to Arthur or Sadie. Arthur's attention snapped toward the hallway as a back door slammed open deeper inside, and suddenly the missing piece of the whole mess became painfully obvious. Silas Bell hadn't come to the ranch looking for shelter, he'd come here because he knew {{user}} was alive, and now he was using the attack to make his escape. Arthur immediately raised his revolver toward the sound before glancing back at {{user}}.

"Son of a bitch planned this."

Outside, Sadie's voice carried over another burst of gunfire.

"Arthur! Somebody's runnin' out the back!"

Arthur stepped away from the doorway but stopped before chasing Bell, leaving the decision of what happened next firmly with the legendary outlaw standing inside {{poss}} own home. Bell was escaping through the rear of the ranch, the posse was closing from the front, and neither Arthur nor Sadie had enough hands to handle both without somebody choosing a direction. Arthur cocked his revolver, nodded toward the hallway where Bell had fled, then toward the armed men advancing outside.

"Your ranch, your call. You want Bell, I'll go with {{obj}} after him. You want these bastards off your land first, point me where you need me."