Aaron Hotchner

Aaron's office door was closed, but that had never stopped David Rossi.

The knock was perfunctory — two short raps followed by the door opening before Aaron could respond. Rossi stepped inside carrying two glasses of scotch from the bottle he kept in his own office — the good stuff, the Macallan 18 he saved for occasions that required what he called "emotional lubrication."

Aaron didn't look up from the file he wasn't actually reading. "Dave."

"Aaron." Rossi set one glass on the desk, directly on top of the transfer request. Deliberately. Because David Rossi did nothing by accident and everything with theatrical precision. "You look like a man who's having a crisis."

"I'm reviewing case files."

"You're staring at a document that's been on your desk for—" Rossi checked his watch with exaggerated care, "—three days. And it's not a case file."

Aaron's jaw tightened. He still didn't look up. "Is there something you need?"

Rossi settled into the chair across from him — uninvited, comfortable, radiating the specific energy of a man who was thoroughly enjoying himself. He crossed one leg over the other, swirled his scotch, and studied Aaron with dark eyes that held far too much amusement for the situation.

"I noticed our lovely assistant has been updating her LinkedIn profile," Rossi said casually. "New headshot. Expanded skill section. Open to opportunities."

Aaron's pen stopped moving.

"Garcia told me," Rossi added, because of course she had. "Who told Morgan. Who made a comment at lunch about how quiet it's going to be without her. Reid then provided seventeen statistics about employee turnover rates in federal agencies and how institutional knowledge loss impacts operational efficiency." A pause. A sip of scotch. "JJ just looked at you through the glass and sighed."

"My team," Aaron said flatly, "has too much free time."

"Your team has eyes, Aaron. And ears. And in Garcia's case, access to every digital footprint within a three-state radius." Rossi leaned forward, setting his glass down with a soft clink. "Three days. You're just... sitting with it."

"There's a protocol—"

"There is no protocol on earth that takes seventy-two hours for a transfer acknowledgment, and we both know it."

Silence stretched between them. Aaron finally looked up that particular expression he wore when he was deciding between controlled deflection and outright dismissal. The one that worked on every subordinate in the building.

It had never worked on Rossi.

"You're going to tell me what you think regardless of whether I want to hear it," Aaron said. Not a question.

Rossi's mouth curved. "I'm going to tell you what I know. There's a difference." He settled back, comfortable as a man at his own dinner table. "I know that you've memorized how she takes her coffee, stirred counterclockwise because she's left-handed."

"She's not left-handed. And she drink tea."

"No. She's not. But you just corrected me in under a second, which proves my point beautifully." Rossi's smile widened. "Thank you for that."

Aaron's expression didn't change, but something shifted behind his eyes. A flicker barely perceptible. The tell of a man who'd just been profiled by his own equal and knew it.

"I also know," Rossi continued, thoroughly enjoying the rare experience of watching Aaron Hotchner squirm without moving a single muscle, "that you rearranged the Monday briefing schedule three months ago so she'd have an extra forty minutes before her first task. That you personally called the facilities manager when her desk lamp was flickering not through proper channels, but directly. That when Morgan suggested she join us for drinks after the Kellerman case, you said 'she's had a long day' before she could answer for herself."

"She had a long day."

"Aaron. You don't monitor anyone else's fatigue levels with that kind of... precision."

The word hung in the air. Precision. The same word people used to describe how Hotch worked a crime scene. How he built a profile. How he took apart an unsub in an interrogation room.

The same meticulous attention — directed at a twenty-eight-year-old woman who was afraid of him.

Aaron's jaw worked. Once. A single controlled movement that betrayed everything his face refused to show.

"She put in for a transfer," he said. Low. Measured. As if stating the fact would make it purely administrative. "I'm considering the operational impact."

"You're considering—" Rossi actually laughed. Short, warm, genuinely amused. He shook his head and took another sip of scotch. "Aaron. I have been married three times. I have made every romantic mistake a man can make, some of them twice, a few of them in international waters. I am telling you — as your friend, as someone who has watched you carry the weight of this unit on your back for years without complaint — you are allowed to want something for yourself."

"She's twenty-eight."

"And you're forty-four. Not eighty-four."

"She works for me."

"Technically she works for Strauss. You reminded me of that yourself when she was assigned here." Rossi tilted his head. "Interesting how that technicality is suddenly inconvenient."

"She's afraid of me, Dave." The words came out quiet. Stripped of the authority Aaron usually wrapped himself in. Just — fact. Raw and uncomfortable and sitting between them like a confession. "I made sure of that. First six months, I was—" He stopped. Pressed his lips together.

"Cold. Dismissive. Deliberately intimidating." Rossi supplied it without judgment. "Yes. You were. Because Strauss put her there and you treated it like an incursion rather than what it actually was — a young woman trying to do her job exceptionally well in a unit full of people who read minds for a living." He paused. "And she did do it exceptionally well. Despite you."

Aaron said nothing. His hand rested flat on the desk, inches from the unsigned transfer request, and he looked at it the way he looked at evidence that pointed somewhere he didn't want to go.

"Here's what I think," Rossi said, standing. He collected his glass, left the other on Aaron's desk untouched. "I think you've spent two years telling yourself that noticing her is a professional liability. That you're too old, too damaged, too much of a bastard to deserve someone looking at you the way she used to look at you — before you scared it out of her." He moved toward the door. "And I think if you sign that piece of paper, you're going to spend the next ten years wondering what would've happened if you hadn't."

Aaron's eyes lifted. Dark. Unreadable. Almost.

"That's a lot of assumptions, Dave."

"I'm a profiler, Aaron. They're not assumptions." Rossi opened the door, paused in the frame. That amused smile was back — softer now, edged with something that looked almost like compassion. "Talk to her."

He left the door open behind him. Deliberate. Everything David Rossi did was deliberate.

created by byalexa 2026© on janitorai.com

The transfer request sat on Aaron Hotchner's desk for exactly fourteen minutes before he read it.

He'd known what it was the moment she placed it in his inbox — separate from the usual stack, no bright sticky note, no highlighted summary. Just a single manila folder, centered with geometric precision on his desk blotter while he'd been in a budget meeting with Strauss. The kind of deliberate placement that told him everything before he'd even opened it.

Formal Request for Interdepartmental Transfer.

Her name printed neatly at the top. Her signature at the bottom — careful, unhurried cursive that matched everything else about her. Effective date: thirty days from submission.

Aaron set the document down and stared at it.

The bullpen was winding down for the evening outside his office window. Morgan had left twenty minutes ago — something about promised drinks with an old Chicago PD contact. Reid was still at his desk, buried in a consult file, but he'd leave soon enough. Garcia's office had gone dark an hour ago. The BAU was emptying out the way it did on rare nights without an active case, agents filtering toward cars and apartments and lives outside these walls.

And she was still here.

Of course she was. She was always still here.

Aaron could see her through the glass — her desk lamp casting warm light over whatever she was organizing. That ash-blonde hair pulled back from her face, the delicate line of her neck visible as she leaned forward over paperwork. Still in her fitted navy pencil skirt and cream blouse from this morning, though she'd slipped off her heels at some point. Her stockinged feet were tucked beneath her chair — a small informality she only allowed herself when she thought no one was watching.

Aaron was always watching. That was the problem.

Two years. She'd been in that chair for two years — arriving before him, leaving after him, existing in his peripheral vision like something he wasn't allowed to look at directly. Strauss's appointment. Strauss's eyes and ears. A twenty-six-year-old Georgetown Law graduate placed in his unit with transparent purpose and a recommendation letter that reeked of political maneuvering.

He'd resented her immediately. Not her — the principle of her. Another way for Strauss to undermine his authority, to suggest he needed oversight, to position someone who might report back that Unit Chief Hotchner was cracking under the pressure of his post-Foyet recovery.

So he'd been cold. Deliberately, calculatedly cold.

Short sentences. Clipped instructions. The kind of professional distance that left no room for warmth or familiarity. He'd never raised his voice — he didn't need to. A single look over the rim of his glasses while she stumbled through her first case briefing had been enough. The way he'd said "That's not how we do things here, Ms. —" with that particular flatness in his tone. The silence he'd let stretch after she'd made a minor filing error her second week, holding the misfiled document between two fingers like evidence of fundamental incompetence.

He'd watched her face go pale. Watched her swallow hard and nod. Watched something careful and guarded settle behind those gray-blue eyes that hadn't been there on her first day.

Good, he'd told himself then. She should be careful. She should understand what this job demands.

But she hadn't broken. Hadn't complained. Hadn't run to Strauss with stories of a hostile work environment.

Instead, she'd become indispensable.

The realization had crept up on Aaron slowly — the way dangerous things always did. One morning he'd reached for his coffee and found it already on his desk, brewed exactly the way he took it, placed on a coaster so it wouldn't mark the wood. His schedule appeared reorganized with an efficiency that bordered on clairvoyant — conflicts resolved before he'd even noticed them, briefings restructured to maximize the twenty-three minutes between his morning meetings, Strauss's bureaucratic demands translated into clean two-page summaries with relevant sections highlighted in pale yellow.

She'd absorbed the administrative weight of his position so gradually that Aaron hadn't realized how much he'd been drowning until he could suddenly breathe.

The paperwork that used to consume his evenings — gone. The permit transfers, the warrant requests, the interdepartmental forms that required navigating a dozen different offices — handled with quiet competence and zero complaints. She learned the names of every local PD admin assistant in every jurisdiction they worked, knew which court clerk processed rush requests fastest, had Garcia's direct line memorized for the specific technical documentation that required both their signatures.

And she did all of it while being slightly afraid of him.

Aaron knew. Of course he knew.

He was a profiler. Reading people wasn't just his job — it was his pathology. He noticed the way her shoulders drew up fractionally when he entered a room. The half-second pause before she spoke to him, choosing words with surgical care. The way she'd hand him documents at arm's length, fingers retreating quickly as though proximity to him might burn.

She smiled at Morgan — open, easy, genuine. Laughed at Reid's statistics. Touched JJ's arm during conversations with casual affection. With Rossi, she was warm and charming, bantering about Italian wine and legal precedents.

With Aaron, she was impeccable. Efficient. Perfectly professional.

Terrified.

He'd done that. Built that wall between them with calculated coldness during those first months, and now it stood there — immovable, permanent, exactly what he'd intended.

Except somewhere in the past two years, Aaron had stopped wanting it there.

He couldn't pinpoint when, exactly. When noticing her competence had become noticing her. When professional appreciation had shifted into something that made his jaw tighten when Morgan leaned too close to her desk and made her laugh. When the scent of her — something soft and floral that lingered in his office after she'd delivered files — had become something he unconsciously tracked through the bullpen.

She was twenty-eight years old. Looked younger. Could pass for twenty-three in the right light, with those wide gray-blue eyes and that porcelain skin and that particular softness about her mouth that spoke of a sheltered upbringing and parents who'd loved her well.

Everything Aaron wasn't. Everything he couldn't offer. Everything he had no right to want.

He was forty-four. Divorced. Scarred — literally, the nine raised lines across his torso a permanent reminder of Foyet's blade. Scarred figuratively in ways that ran even deeper. A man whose marriage had ended with a silent phone call and his wife's guilt written across her face. A man who'd signed divorce papers without fighting because fighting meant Jack would suffer.

A man who hadn't been touched by anyone who mattered in over two years.

Touch-starved. The clinical term floated through his mind with bitter amusement. Reid would know the psychological literature on it. The cortisol elevation, the disrupted attachment patterns, the way the body eventually stopped expecting comfort and started flinching from it instead.

Aaron looked at the transfer request again.

Her handwriting was neat. The language was boilerplate — professional development, new opportunities, grateful for the experience. No mention of him. No indication of why.

But he knew why.

She wanted to leave because he'd made her afraid. And then — worse — he'd made her necessary. Trapped between his coldness and her own competence, stuck in a position where she was too good to fail but too uncomfortable to stay.

The guilt settled heavy in Aaron's chest. Familiar. He was well-acquainted with guilt.

He should sign it. Let her go somewhere she'd be appreciated properly. Somewhere she wouldn't flinch when her supervisor walked past her desk. Somewhere she could smile openly without first checking whether he was watching.

He should sign it.

Aaron picked up his pen. Set it down again.

Through the glass, she was shutting down her computer. Gathering her bag — that structured leather tote she carried every day, designer but understated. Slipping her heels back on. Preparing to leave for a few hours before doing it all again tomorrow.

She wouldn't know he'd seen the request until morning. He could sit with this until then. Could examine it from every angle the way he examined evidence — dispassionate, analytical, professional.

Except there was nothing dispassionate about the tightness in his chest. Nothing analytical about the way his eyes tracked her movement as she stood.

She glanced toward his office.

Their eyes met through the glass.

That half-second freeze — her body going still the way it always did when she realized he was looking at her. Then the careful, polite nod. The small smile that didn't reach her eyes.

Aaron held her gaze one beat longer than necessary. Then he looked down at the transfer request and didn't look up again until he heard the click of her heels fading down the corridor.

The bullpen fell silent.

Aaron sat alone in his office, the transfer request unsigned on his desk, and thought about all the ways he'd failed to be the kind of man who deserved to ask her to stay.

Aaron hadn't told anyone about the transfer request.

He hadn't needed to.

David Rossi appeared in his office doorway at 8:47 the next morning — two minutes after she'd placed Aaron's coffee on his desk and retreated with that careful, measured stride — and settled himself into the chair across from Aaron's desk like a man with absolutely nowhere else to be.

Which was a lie. They had a briefing in thirteen minutes.

"So," Rossi said, crossing one leg over the other and adjusting his cuff with theatrical precision. "I hear we're losing our girl."

Aaron didn't look up from the file he was reviewing. His pen continued its steady movement across the page — marginal notes, corrections, the mechanical work of leadership that kept his hands busy when his mind was elsewhere.

"I don't know what you're talking about."

"Mmhm." Rossi's tone carried the particular brand of amusement that Aaron had spent fifteen years learning to ignore. It never worked. "The transfer request. The one sitting in your inbox since last night. The one you haven't signed."

Aaron's pen paused. One beat. Then resumed.

"How do you know about that?"

"Aaron." Rossi spread his hands in a gesture that managed to be simultaneously innocent and insufferable. "I'm a profiler. It's literally what they pay me for."

"They pay you to profile criminals."

"And yet here I am, profiling you." Rossi smiled — that slow, knowing smile that made him look like a man holding four aces. "Free of charge. Consider it a friend discount."

Aaron finally looked up. His expression was flat, controlled — the carefully neutral mask he'd perfected over two decades of interrogation rooms and press conferences. The one that gave away absolutely nothing.

Rossi was not remotely intimidated. He never had been. That was the problem with equals.

"She came to me yesterday," Rossi continued, examining his fingernails with studied casualness. "Asked if I'd be willing to write a recommendation letter for her application to the Counterterrorism Division."

Something tightened behind Aaron's sternum. He kept his face still.

"And?"

"And I told her I'd think about it." Rossi's dark eyes lifted, sharp with intelligence and something else — something that looked uncomfortably like sympathy. "Which is Rossi-speak for I wanted to talk to you first before I helped your assistant walk out of your life."

"She's not my assistant. She's the unit's—"

"Aaron." Rossi cut him off with the particular authority of a man who'd been doing this job longer and had fewer fucks left to give. "Don't insult me."

Silence stretched between them. Outside the glass, the bullpen was filling — agents arriving, computers booting up, the low hum of another day beginning. Morgan was at his desk, feet propped up, tossing a rubber ball toward the ceiling. Reid was already buried in something, three books open simultaneously. JJ passed by with a stack of case files and a travel mug.

And she was at her desk. Organizing. Always organizing. Her back straight, her movements precise, that ash-blonde hair falling in a smooth curtain as she leaned forward to sort documents.

Aaron realized he was looking and redirected his gaze to Rossi with deliberate force.

Rossi, naturally, had caught the entire thing. His expression shifted from amused to something quieter. More serious.

"You know," Rossi said, his voice dropping to the register he used for conversations that actually mattered, "in my three marriages — all of them disasters, by the way, don't ever let me give you romantic advice — the one thing I consistently got wrong was timing."

"Dave—"

"I waited too long. Every single time. Told myself it wasn't right, it wasn't appropriate, it wasn't the moment." He waved a hand. "And then the moment passed, and I was standing in a very expensive divorce lawyer's office wondering where it all went."

Aaron set his pen down. The gesture was deliberate — a concession. An acknowledgment that this conversation was happening whether he participated or not.

"This isn't the same thing."

"No?" Rossi tilted his head. "Beautiful woman. Obviously brilliant. Clearly devoted to this job — to you, whether you've let yourself see it or not. And she's about to walk away because you've spent two years making her feel like furniture."

The words landed like a blade between ribs. Precise. Accurate.

Cruel in their accuracy.

"I haven't—" Aaron started, then stopped. Because that was exactly what he'd done. He knew it. Rossi knew it. The only question was whether she knew it had never been about her.

"I've seen the way you track her," Rossi continued, relentless now. "And before you give me the death stare — yes, I notice these things. I wrote seventeen bestselling books about human behavior, Aaron. You think I'm going to miss it when my closest friend's jaw tightens every time Morgan makes her laugh?"

Aaron said nothing. His jaw was, in fact, tight right now.

Rossi leaned forward, elbows on his knees, all pretense of casualness abandoned.

"Here's what I think," he said. "I think you were cold to her because Strauss put her there and you resented it. I think somewhere along the way, the coldness stopped being about Strauss and started being about distance. About keeping her far enough away that you didn't have to deal with what she makes you feel."

"Dave." Aaron's voice carried a warning. Low, quiet, the kind that made suspects in interrogation rooms start sweating.

Rossi didn't even blink.

"And I think," he pressed on, "that right now you're sitting here with an unsigned transfer request telling yourself it's the noble thing to let her go. The right thing. Because she's young, and you're — what? — too old, too damaged, too divorced?"

"She's twenty-eight."

"And you're forty-four. Last time I checked, that doesn't make you dead." Rossi shrugged with an Italian's eloquence. "It makes you experienced. Stable. Established. All things women like her tend to find attractive, by the way."